Evaluation of a compact, rechargeable, magnifying device to triage VIA and HPV positive women in a cervical cancer screening program in rural India

被引:18
作者
Basu, Partha [1 ]
Banerjee, Dipanwita [2 ]
Mittal, Srabani [2 ]
Mandal, Ranajit [2 ]
Ghosh, Ishita [2 ]
Das, Pradip [2 ]
Muwonge, Richard [1 ]
Biswas, Jaydip [2 ]
机构
[1] Int Agcy Res Canc WHO, Early Detect & Prevent Sect, Screening Grp, 150 Cours Albert Thomas, F-69372 Lyon 08, France
[2] Chittaranjan Natl Canc Inst, Kolkata, W Bengal, India
关键词
Visual inspection after acetic acid application; Human papillomavirus test; Triaging; Magnifying device; GynocularTM; MIDDLE-INCOME COUNTRIES; SWEDE SCORE; COLPOSCOPY; SYSTEM; NEOPLASIA; ACCURACY;
D O I
10.1007/s10552-016-0805-7
中图分类号
R73 [肿瘤学];
学科分类号
100214 ;
摘要
Many limited-resourced countries have either introduced cervical cancer screening programs or are contemplating to do so using visual inspection after acetic acid application (VIA) or human papillomavirus (HPV) detection tests. Both tests have high false-positivity and a suitable triaging strategy is required. Colposcopy triaging is not practicable in most resource-limited settings due to several reasons. We evaluated a portable, battery-operated, magnifying device (GynocularTM) to triage screen positive women in community setting in India. Women positive on VIA or oncogenic HPV test were examined with Gynocular by clinicians in primary health clinics. Findings were documented using the International Federation for Cervical Pathology and Colposcopy (IFCPC) terminology. Swede score was also calculated. Biopsy was performed irrespective of Gynocular findings. The accuracy of Gynocular to detect high-grade lesions or cancer (HSIL+) was estimated. The suitability of Gynocular to correctly triage screen positive cases for immediate ablative treatment was also evaluated by creating simulated scenarios. Sensitivity and specificity of Gynocular were 96.4 and 47.1 %, respectively, to detect HSIL + at the threshold of IFCPC grade 1 findings. Increasing threshold to grade 2 changed sensitivity and specificity to 92.9 and 94.1 %, respectively. Optimum combination of sensitivity and specificity as determined by the receiver operating curve analysis was at the cut-off Swede score of 5. Triaging of VIA/HPV positive women to treatment using grade 2 criteria would have resulted in modest overtreatment and missing of very few high-grade lesions. Gynocular can be used as an effective triaging device for VIA/HPV positive women.
引用
收藏
页码:1253 / 1259
页数:7
相关论文
共 17 条
[1]   Diagnostic accuracy of VIA and HPV detection as primary and sequential screening tests in a cervical cancer screening demonstration project in India [J].
Basu, Partha ;
Mittal, Srabani ;
Banerjee, Dipanwita ;
Singh, Priyanka ;
Panda, Chinmay ;
Dutta, Sankhadeep ;
Mandal, Ranajit ;
Das, Pradip ;
Biswas, Jaydip ;
Muwonge, Richard ;
Sankaranarayanan, Rengaswamy .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CANCER, 2015, 137 (04) :859-867
[2]   2011 Colposcopic Terminology of the International Federation for Cervical Pathology and Colposcopy [J].
Bornstein, Jacob ;
Bentley, James ;
Boesze, Peter ;
Girardi, Frank ;
Haefner, Hope ;
Menton, Michael ;
Perrotta, Myriam ;
Prendiville, Walter ;
Russell, Peter ;
Sideri, Mario ;
Strander, Bjorrn ;
Tatti, Silvio ;
Torne, Aureli ;
Walker, Patrick .
OBSTETRICS AND GYNECOLOGY, 2012, 120 (01) :166-172
[3]   The Swede Score: Evaluation of a Scoring System Designed to Improve the Predictive Value of Colposcopy [J].
Bowring, Julie ;
Strander, Bjorn ;
Young, Martin ;
Evans, Heather ;
Walker, Patrick .
JOURNAL OF LOWER GENITAL TRACT DISEASE, 2010, 14 (04) :301-305
[4]  
Control Comprehensive Cervical Cancer, 2014, GUID ESS PRACT
[5]  
Dos Santos Silva I., 1999, CANC EPIDEMIOLOGY PR
[6]  
Ferlay J., 2013, GLOBOCAN 2012 CANC I
[7]   Study of accuracy of colposcopy in VIA and HPV detection-based cervical cancer screening program [J].
Ghosh, Ishita ;
Mittal, Srabani ;
Banerjee, Dipanwita ;
Singh, Priyanka ;
Dasgupta, Sujoy ;
Chatterjee, Simi ;
Biswas, Jaydip ;
Panda, Chinmay ;
Basu, Partha .
AUSTRALIAN & NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF OBSTETRICS & GYNAECOLOGY, 2014, 54 (06) :570-575
[8]   Evaluation of the accuracy in detecting cervical lesions by nurses versus doctors using a stationary colposcope and Gynocular in a low-resource setting [J].
Nessa, Ashrafun ;
Roy, Joya Shree ;
Chowdhury, Most Afroza ;
Khanam, Quayuma ;
Afroz, Romena ;
Wistrand, Charlotte ;
Thuresson, Marcus ;
Thorsell, Malin ;
Shemer, Isaac ;
Shemer, Elisabeth Andrea Wikstrom .
BMJ OPEN, 2014, 4 (11)
[9]   Evaluation of Stationary Colposcope and the Gynocular, by the Swede Score Systematic Colposcopic System in VIA Positive Women A Crossover Randomized Trial [J].
Nessa, Ashrafun ;
Wistrand, Charlotte ;
Begum, Shirin Akter ;
Thuresson, Marcus ;
Shemer, Isaac ;
Thorsell, Malin ;
Shemer, Elisabeth Andrea Wikstrom .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF GYNECOLOGICAL CANCER, 2014, 24 (02) :339-345
[10]   Agreement of Colposcope and Gynocular in Assessment of Cervical Lesions by Swede Score: A Randomized, Crossover Pilot Trial [J].
Ngonzi, Joseph ;
Bajunirwe, Francis ;
Wistrand, Charlotte ;
Mayanja, Ronald ;
Altman, Daniel ;
Thorsell, Malin ;
Shemer, Wikstrom Elisabeth Andrea .
JOURNAL OF LOWER GENITAL TRACT DISEASE, 2013, 17 (04) :372-377