Plant-to-planet analysis of CO2-based methanol processes

被引:194
作者
Gonzalez-Garay, Andres [1 ]
Frei, Matthias S. [2 ]
Al-Qahtani, Amjad [1 ]
Mondelli, Cecilia [2 ]
Guillen-Gosalbez, Gonzalo [2 ]
Perez-Ramirez, Javier [2 ]
机构
[1] Imperial Coll London, Ctr Proc Syst Engn, London SW7 2AZ, England
[2] Swiss Fed Inst Technol, Inst Chem & Bioengn, Dept Chem & Appl Biosci, Vladimir Prelog Weg 1, CH-8093 Zurich, Switzerland
关键词
LIFE-CYCLE ASSESSMENT; HYDROGEN-PRODUCTION; RENEWABLE HYDROGEN; CO2; HYDROGENATION; CAPTURED CO2; SOCIAL COST; CARBON; OPTIMIZATION; HYDROCARBONS; TECHNOLOGIES;
D O I
10.1039/c9ee01673b
中图分类号
O6 [化学];
学科分类号
0703 ;
摘要
A critical assessment of methanol production from carbon dioxide and renewable hydrogen is here presented, gathering an insightful picture of its wide sustainability and establishing a hierarchy of factors dictating its performance. Process simulation and life-cycle analysis indicate that green methanol is at present economically unattractive, i.e., it has a 1.3-2.6-fold higher cost compared to the current fossilbased analogue, even when considering indirect environmental costs via monetisation of impacts and a potential CO2 tax of at least 430.5 USD tCO2- eq1. This is mainly due to the high price of hydrogen (water electrolysis powered with solar, wind, and nuclear energy, or biomass gasification, up to 73% of the total cost), which shall drop significantly due to reductions in electricity costs and technological advances. The scenario radically changes when quantifying for the first time the absolute sustainability of this carbon capture and utilisation route through eight planetary boundaries, revealing that CO2-based methanol would contribute to operating safely within critical ecological limits of the Earth linked to carbon emissions, currently transgressed by the conventional process. Our plant-to-planet assessment embraces the full potential role of emerging processes in sustainable development, which should prevail over purely economic arguments, subject to market fluctuations and technological advances.
引用
收藏
页码:3425 / 3436
页数:12
相关论文
共 54 条
[1]   Life cycle burden-shifting in energy systems designed to minimize greenhouse gas emissions: Novel analytical method and application to the United States [J].
Algunaibet, Ibrahim M. ;
Guillen-Gosalbez, Gonzalo .
JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION, 2019, 229 :886-901
[2]   Powering sustainable development within planetary boundaries [J].
Algunaibet, Ibrahim M. ;
Pozo, Carlos ;
Galan-Martin, Angel ;
Huijbregts, Mark A. J. ;
Mac Dowell, Niall ;
Guillen-Gosalbez, Gonzalo .
ENERGY & ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE, 2019, 12 (06) :1890-1900
[3]   Challenges in the Greener Production of Formates/Formic Acid, Methanol, and DME by Heterogeneously Catalyzed CO2 Hydrogenation Processes [J].
Alvarez, Andrea ;
Bansode, Atul ;
Urakawa, Atsushi ;
Bavykina, Anastasiya V. ;
Wezendonk, Tim A. ;
Makkee, Michiel ;
Gascon, Jorge ;
Kapteijn, Freek .
CHEMICAL REVIEWS, 2017, 117 (14) :9804-9838
[4]  
Behr A., 2014, ANGEW CHEM INT EDIT, V53, P12674, DOI [10.1002/anie.201409583, DOI 10.1002/ANIE.201409583]
[5]   Promoting the Synthesis of Methanol: Understanding the Requirements for an Industrial Catalyst for the Conversion of CO2 [J].
Behrens, Malte .
ANGEWANDTE CHEMIE-INTERNATIONAL EDITION, 2016, 55 (48) :14906-14908
[6]   A comprehensive review on PEM water electrolysis [J].
Carmo, Marcelo ;
Fritz, David L. ;
Merge, Juergen ;
Stolten, Detlef .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HYDROGEN ENERGY, 2013, 38 (12) :4901-4934
[7]   Life cycle assessment of various hydrogen production methods [J].
Cetinkaya, E. ;
Dincer, I. ;
Naterer, G. F. .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HYDROGEN ENERGY, 2012, 37 (03) :2071-2080
[8]  
Chin K, 2015, CHEM ENG PROG, V111, P36
[9]   Carbon capture, storage and utilisation technologies: A critical analysis and comparison of their life cycle environmental impacts [J].
Cuellar-Franca, Rosa M. ;
Azapagic, Adisa .
JOURNAL OF CO2 UTILIZATION, 2015, 9 :82-102
[10]   Closing the carbon cycle to maximise climate change mitigation: power-to-methanol vs. power-to-direct air capture [J].
Daggash, H. A. ;
Patzschke, C. F. ;
Heuberger, C. F. ;
Zhu, L. ;
Hellgardt, K. ;
Fennell, P. S. ;
Bhave, A. N. ;
Bardow, A. ;
Mac Dowell, N. .
SUSTAINABLE ENERGY & FUELS, 2018, 2 (06) :1153-1169