Assessing spatial predictive models in the environmental sciences: Accuracy measures, data variation and variance explained

A comprehensive assessment of the performance of predictive models is necessary as they have been increasingly employed to generate spatial predictions for environmental management and conservation and their accuracy is crucial to evidence-informed decision making and, policy. In this study, we clarified relevant issues associated with variance explained (VEcv) by predictive models, established the relationships between VEcv and commonly used accuracy measures and unified these measures under VEcv that is independent of unit/scale and data variation. We quantified the relationships between these measures and data variation and found about 65% compared models and over 45% recommended models for generating spatial predictions explained no more than 50% data variance. We classified the predictive models based on VEcv, which provides a tool to directly compare the accuracy of predictive models for data with different unit/scale and variation and establishes a cross-disciplinary context and benchmark for assessing predictive models in future studies. (C) 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.