Numerical homogenization of a linearly elastic honeycomb lattice structure and with and results

This paper presents a verification and validation analysis of Finite Element (FE) models predicting the mechanical response of linearly elastic honeycomb structures. We have studied three main models, namely: analytical models based on beam theories, explicit FE models where the cell geometry is explicitly meshed with 3D elements, and numerical homogenized FE models where a plate made of a honeycomb structure is meshed with 2D elements whose mechanical properties were predicted from numerical homogenization. We compared the predictions of these simulations against experimental uni-axial tensile tests where we mechanically tested 3D printed honeycomb specimens having a relative density of 40% and made of 13 and 37 cells, respectively. Comparison of the experimentally measured axial stiffness to the numerical predictions revealed that the numerical homogenization models can predict the apparent in-plane stiffness in structures made of 37 cells within 4%, while the discrepancy increases to 70% when 13 cells are considered. To quantify this discrepancy, we also provided a relationship between the number of represented cells and the discrepancy of the numerical homogenized model against the explicit FE models to predict the in-plane stiffness. We believe that these results could be important for the application of the homogenized models in optimization of honeycomb lattice structures whose relative density varies with space.