Observations on screening-based research and some concerning trends in the literature

被引:83
作者
Baell, Jonathan B. [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Melbourne, Walter & Eliza Hall Inst Med Res, Dept Med Biol, Bundoora, Vic 3086, Australia
[2] Canc Therapeut CRC Pty Ltd, Bundoora, Vic 3086, Australia
关键词
SMALL-MOLECULE INHIBITORS; FALSE POSITIVES; IDENTIFICATION; RECEPTOR; BINDING; ASSAY; COMPLEXES; COVALENT;
D O I
10.4155/FMC.10.237
中图分类号
R914 [药物化学];
学科分类号
100701 ;
摘要
Academic drug discovery is being accompanied by a plethora of publications that report screening hits as good starting points for drug discovery or as useful tool compounds, whereas in many cases this is not so. These compounds may be protein-reactive but can also interfere in bioassays via a number of other means, and it can be very hard to prove early on that they represent false starts. This, for instance, makes it difficult for journals in their assessment of manuscripts submitted for publication. Wider awareness and recognition of these problematic compounds will help the academic drug-discovery community focus on and publish genuinely optimizable screening hits. This will be of general benefit.
引用
收藏
页码:1529 / 1546
页数:18
相关论文
共 38 条
  • [1] Chemical genetics screen for enhancers of rapamycin identifies a specific inhibitor of an SCF family E3 ubiquitin ligase
    Aghajan, Mariam
    Jonai, Nao
    Flick, Karin
    Fu, Fei
    Luo, Manlin
    Cai, Xiaolu
    Ouni, Ikram
    Pierce, Nathan
    Tang, Xiaobo
    Lomenick, Brett
    Damoiseaux, Robert
    Hao, Rui
    del Moral, Pierre M.
    Verma, Rati
    Li, Ying
    Li, Cheng
    Houk, Kendall N.
    Jung, Michael E.
    Zheng, Ning
    Huang, Lan
    Deshaies, Raymond J.
    Kaiser, Peter
    Huang, Jing
    [J]. NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY, 2010, 28 (07) : 738 - U1750
  • [2] Cytotoxicity of salicylaldehyde benzoylhydrazone analogs and their transition metal complexes: quantitative structure-activity relationships
    Ainscough, EW
    Brodie, AM
    Denny, WA
    Finlay, GJ
    Gothe, SA
    Ranford, JD
    [J]. JOURNAL OF INORGANIC BIOCHEMISTRY, 1999, 77 (3-4) : 125 - 133
  • [3] Discovery of small molecule inhibitors of the interaction of the thyroid hormone receptor with transcriptional coregulators
    Arnold, LA
    Estébanez-Perpiñá, E
    Togashi, M
    Jouravel, N
    Shelat, A
    McReynolds, AC
    Mar, E
    Nguyen, P
    Baxter, JD
    Fletterick, RJ
    Webb, P
    Guy, RK
    [J]. JOURNAL OF BIOLOGICAL CHEMISTRY, 2005, 280 (52) : 43048 - 43055
  • [4] New Substructure Filters for Removal of Pan Assay Interference Compounds (PAINS) from Screening Libraries and for Their Exclusion in Bioassays
    Baell, Jonathan B.
    Holloway, Georgina A.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF MEDICINAL CHEMISTRY, 2010, 53 (07) : 2719 - 2740
  • [5] Virtual Ligand Screening of the p300/CBP Histone Acetyltransferase: Identification of a Selective Small Molecule Inhibitor
    Bowers, Erin M.
    Yan, Gai
    Mukherjee, Chandrani
    Orry, Andrew
    Wang, Ling
    Holbert, Marc A.
    Crump, Nicholas T.
    Hazzalin, Catherine A.
    Liszczak, Glen
    Yuan, Hua
    Larocca, Cecilia
    Saldanha, S. Adrian
    Abagyan, Ruben
    Sun, Yan
    Meyers, David J.
    Marmorstein, Ronen
    Mahadevan, Louis C.
    Alani, Rhoda M.
    Cole, Philip A.
    [J]. CHEMISTRY & BIOLOGY, 2010, 17 (05): : 471 - 482
  • [6] Naphthyl ketones: A new class of Janus kinase 3 inhibitors
    Brown, GR
    Bamford, AM
    Bowyer, J
    James, DS
    Rankine, N
    Tang, E
    Torr, V
    Culbert, EJ
    [J]. BIOORGANIC & MEDICINAL CHEMISTRY LETTERS, 2000, 10 (06) : 575 - 579
  • [7] Chemical probes of UDP-galactopyranose mutase
    Carlson, Erin E.
    May, John F.
    Kiessling, Laura L.
    [J]. CHEMISTRY & BIOLOGY, 2006, 13 (08): : 825 - 837
  • [8] Photochemically enhanced binding of small molecules to the tumor necrosis factor receptor-1 inhibits the binding of TNF-α
    Carter, PH
    Scherle, PA
    Muckelbauer, JA
    Voss, ME
    Liu, RQ
    Thompson, LA
    Tebben, AJ
    Solomon, KA
    Lo, YC
    Li, Z
    Strzemienski, P
    Yang, GJ
    Falahatpisheh, N
    Xu, M
    Wu, ZR
    Farrow, NA
    Ramnarayan, K
    Wang, J
    Rideout, D
    Yalamoori, V
    Domaille, P
    Underwood, DJ
    Trzaskos, JM
    Friedman, SM
    Newton, RC
    Decicco, CP
    [J]. PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, 2001, 98 (21) : 11879 - 11884
  • [9] Identification of small-molecule inhibitors of interaction between the BH3 domain and Bcl-xL
    Degterev, A
    Lugovskoy, A
    Cardone, M
    Mulley, B
    Wagner, G
    Mitchison, T
    Yuan, JY
    [J]. NATURE CELL BIOLOGY, 2001, 3 (02) : 173 - 182
  • [10] Efficient synthetic inhibitors of anthrax lethal factor
    Forino, M
    Johnson, S
    Wong, TY
    Rozanov, DV
    Savinov, AY
    Li, W
    Fattorusso, R
    Becattini, B
    Orry, AJ
    Jung, DW
    Abagyan, RA
    Smith, JW
    Alibek, K
    Liddington, RC
    Strongin, AY
    Pellecchia, M
    [J]. PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, 2005, 102 (27) : 9499 - 9504