A comparison of safety analysis techniques: Analytical calculations versus Monte Carlo simulations

被引：0
|
作者：
Mueller, J. R. [1 ]
Staender, T. [1 ]
Schnieder, E. [1 ]
机构：
[1] Tech Univ Carolo Wilhelmina Braunschweig, Inst Traff Safety & Automat Engn, Braunschweig, Germany
来源：
RELIABILITY, RISK AND SAFETY: THEORY AND APPLICATIONS VOLS 1-3 | 2010年
关键词：
D O I：
暂无
中图分类号：
TP301 [理论、方法];
学科分类号：
081202 ;
摘要：
According to IEC 61508 the assessment of the Safety Integrity Level for a safety related system requires the calculation of the probability of failure on demand (PFD). Part 6 of IEC 61508 provides formulas for redundant and homogeneous systems. In contrast to this, industrial systems are often designed heterogeneously, in order to reduce to probability of common cause failures. The paper therefore provides a comparative examination of an analytical calculation, Markov and Petri net simulation at a running example of a heterogeneous 1 out of 2 (loo2)-structure. The comparison of the derivative of the corresponding analytical formula and the model based approaches underline the need of dependability engineers for more user-friendly, graphical and intuitive support.
引用
收藏
页码：1483 / 1487
页数：5
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Comparison of analytical theory with Monte Carlo simulations
    Jansen, G.H.
    Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, 2024, 230 : 437 - 454
  • [2] COMPARISON OF MONTE-CARLO AND ANALYTICAL CALCULATIONS IN QCD
    INGELMAN, G
    SOPER, DE
    PHYSICS LETTERS B, 1984, 148 (1-3) : 171 - 176
  • [3] POLYMER MELTS BETWEEN PLATES - ANALYTICAL CALCULATIONS AND MONTE-CARLO SIMULATIONS
    KUMAR, SK
    AUSSERRE, D
    VACATELLO, M
    DO, Y
    ABSTRACTS OF PAPERS OF THE AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY, 1989, 197 : 195 - POLY
  • [4] Radiation dose around a PET scanner installation: Comparison of Monte Carlo simulations, analytical calculations and experimental results
    Lo Meo, S.
    Cicoria, G.
    Campanella, F.
    Mattozzi, M.
    Panebianco, A. S.
    Marengo, M.
    PHYSICA MEDICA-EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF MEDICAL PHYSICS, 2014, 30 (04): : 448 - 453
  • [5] The resolution of the tof-backscattering spectrometer OSIRIS: Monte Carlo simulations and analytical calculations
    Demmel, F.
    Pokhilchuk, K.
    NUCLEAR INSTRUMENTS & METHODS IN PHYSICS RESEARCH SECTION A-ACCELERATORS SPECTROMETERS DETECTORS AND ASSOCIATED EQUIPMENT, 2014, 767 : 426 - 432
  • [6] Comparison of Different Build-Up Factor Calculations with Monte Carlo Simulations
    Bednar, David
    Listjak, Martin
    Slimak, Andrej
    Necas, Vladimir
    APPLIED PHYSICS OF CONDENSED MATTER (APCOM 2019), 2019, 2131
  • [7] COMPARISON OF ANALYTICAL APPROXIMATIONS FOR HYDROGEN IN BCC METALS WITH MONTE-CARLO CALCULATIONS
    MEUFFELS, P
    OATES, WA
    JOURNAL OF THE LESS-COMMON METALS, 1987, 130 : 403 - 413
  • [8] Comparison of Analytical and Monte Carlo Calculations for Heterogeneity Corrections in LDR Prostate Brachytherapy
    Hueso, F.
    Vijande, J.
    Perez-Calatayud, J.
    Ballester, F.
    Siebert, F.
    MEDICAL PHYSICS, 2013, 40 (06)
  • [9] Site-Specific Comparison of Analytical and Monte Carlo Based Dose Calculations
    Schuemann, J.
    Dowdell, S.
    Grassberger, C.
    Paganetti, H.
    MEDICAL PHYSICS, 2014, 41 (06) : 534 - 534
  • [10] Monte Carlo techniques for direct lighting calculations
    Shirley, P
    Wang, CY
    Zimmerman, K
    ACM TRANSACTIONS ON GRAPHICS, 1996, 15 (01): : 1 - 36
12345