On replacing single-use plastic with so-called biodegradable ones: The case with straws

被引:64
作者
Viera, Joao S. C. [1 ]
Marques, Monica R. C. [2 ]
Nazareth, Monick Cruz [2 ]
Jimenez, Paula Christine [1 ]
Castro, Italo Braga [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Fed Sao Paulo IMAR UNIFESP, Inst Mar, Rua Maria Maximo, BR-11030100 Santos, SP, Brazil
[2] Univ Estado Rio De Janeiro, Programa Posgrad Quim, Inst Quim, Rua Sao Francisco Xavier 524, BR-20559900 Rio De Janeiro, SP, Brazil
关键词
Greenwashing; Biodegradable plastic; Polymer; False claims; Pollution; DEGRADATION; POLLUTION; SCIENCE; DEBRIS; BAGS; SEA;
D O I
10.1016/j.envsci.2020.02.007
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
Plastic pollution is a global environmental concern and several approaches have been implemented seeking to reduce and control releases of plastic waste, especially in marine environments. Recently, disclosure of data on occurrence of single-use plastic straws among the litter collected in beach cleaning campaigns unleashed a worldwide movement that resulted on banning of these items in several countries. The market then quickly began to offer sustainable solutions as the professed biodegradable plastic straws. However, cases of green-washing added to current limitations related to the technical standards used to attest biodegradability of commercial plastic products may lead these measures to be largely ineffective. Herein, a case study assessing the composition of plastic straws marketed in Brazil and United States under false claims of biodegradability was used as background for discussion of this neglected issue, which goes far beyond plastics straws. Thus, although some local regulations have already banned single-use plastic products, additional actions in regional and global scales should be implemented, especially concerning proper labeling of the alleged biodegradable products. Therefore, from a multi-dimensional perspective and considering the resistance of the powerful plastic industry, multiple management strategies focused on educating people in the matters of deciding purchases based on correct labeling and properly discarding the waste, are possibly our best chance to drive a positive global environmental change. Additionally, we also suggest the inclusion of this relevant subject among the tasks proposed by the Basel Convention Partnership on Plastic Waste.
引用
收藏
页码:177 / 181
页数:5
相关论文
共 46 条
[31]   The multidimensional effects of single-use and packaging plastic strategies on German household waste management [J].
Schmidt, Sarah ;
Laner, David .
WASTE MANAGEMENT, 2021, 131 :187-200
[32]   Environmental movements in a material world. A relational perspective on single-use plastic in Penzance, UK [J].
Idies, Yusif ;
Moessner, Samuel .
FRONTIERS IN SUSTAINABLE CITIES, 2023, 5
[33]   Closing the loop: A framework for tackling single-use plastic waste in the food and beverage industry through circular economy- a review [J].
Arijeniwa, Victoria Foluke ;
Akinsemolu, Adenike A. ;
Chukwugozie, Deborah C. ;
Onawo, Ulakom Genesis ;
Ochulor, Chidinma Ezinne ;
Nwauzoma, Uju M. ;
Kawino, Dinah Awino ;
Onyeaka, Helen .
JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT, 2024, 359
[34]   Applying the SOR framework to mitigate single-use plastic tableware consumption and why does it work? Solving the dissonance with an extended SOR framework [J].
Levavi, Lilach Rinot ;
Friedmann, Enav ;
Kalagy, Tehila ;
Cohen, Chen .
JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT, 2023, 348
[35]   Single-use plastic bag alternatives result in higher environmental impacts: Multi-regional analysis in country with uneven waste management [J].
Tan, Yiqi ;
Wen, Zongguo ;
Hu, Yupeng ;
Zeng, Xianlai ;
Kosajan, Vorada ;
Yin, Ge ;
Zhang, Tingting .
WASTE MANAGEMENT, 2023, 171 :281-291
[36]   Awareness about Ban on Single-use Plastic Items among Nursing Professionals: A Cross-sectional Survey [J].
Singh, Sukhbir ;
Vashihst, Madan Gopal ;
Mahla, Mahesh ;
Verma, Ramesh ;
Malik, Ishwanti .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL AND DIAGNOSTIC RESEARCH, 2022, 16 (01) :LC1-LC5
[37]   Use of stable carbon isotope ratios to determine the source of cypermethrin in so-called natural plant extract formulations used for organic farming [J].
Kawashima, Hiroto ;
Kariya, Takuro .
ISOTOPES IN ENVIRONMENTAL AND HEALTH STUDIES, 2017, 53 (01) :70-79
[38]   Impact of historic sediment characterisation on predicting polychaete distributions: a case study of so-called muddy habitat shovelhead worms (Annelida: Magelonidae) [J].
Mills, Kimberley ;
Mortimer, Kate .
JOURNAL OF THE MARINE BIOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION OF THE UNITED KINGDOM, 2023, 103
[39]   Jute bags as a sustainable alternative to single-use plastic bags in Bangladesh: Rethinking the sole reliance on life cycle assessment [J].
Zuthi, M. F. R. ;
Khan, F. ;
Lange, I. ;
Jarin, T. T. ;
Masum, M. H. ;
Rahman, M. A. ;
Tasnim, N. ;
Kraft, E. ;
Hoque, A. ;
Hassan, K. M. .
SUSTAINABLE PRODUCTION AND CONSUMPTION, 2025, 56 :54-65
[40]   Toward a Circular Bioeconomy: Development of Pineapple Stem Starch Composite as a Plastic-Sheet Substitute for Single-Use Applications [J].
Thongphang, Chanaporn ;
Namphonsane, Atitiya ;
Thanawan, Sombat ;
Chia, Chin Hua ;
Wongsagonsup, Rungtiwa ;
Smith, Siwaporn Meejoo ;
Amornsakchai, Taweechai .
POLYMERS, 2023, 15 (10)