Genetic Evidence Supports Species Delimitation of Luidia in the Northern Gulf of Mexico

Accurate species delimitation is crucial to understanding biodiversity. In the northern Gulf of Mexico, recent genetic evidence has suggested that the tricolor Luidia lawrencei is not a species distinct from the gray Luidia clathrata. We collected Luidia specimens from Apalachee Bay, Florida, and morphologically identified 11 as L. clathrata and 16 as L. lawrencei. We sequenced 1074 bp of the cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) and found similar to 14% divergence between L. clathrata and L. lawrencei, suggesting two distinct species (within-species divergence was <1%). Two specimens were phenotypically L. lawrencei (i.e., tricolor morph) but mitochondrially were L. clathrata. Our findings lend support to maintaining L. clathrata and L. lawrencei as distinct species. However, the species boundary between these two taxa may be porous, and ongoing hybridization may occur when the two species are found in sympatry. Future work with nuclear markers is warranted to determine the frequency of hybridization and the extent of introgression. Clarifying the genetic relationship between these species will provide a baseline for assessing ongoing changes in connectivity of these two highly abundant sea stars in the rapidly warming northern Gulf of Mexico.