Monogamy does not last long in Pontonia mexicana, a symbiotic shrimp of the amber pen-shell Pinna carnea from the southeastern Caribbean Sea

Theory suggests that symbiotic species should be monogamous and form long-lasting heterosexual pairs in/on hosts when inhabiting scarce and small hosts in environments where predation risk away from hosts is high (e.g., tropical subtidal). This prediction was tested with Pontonia mexicana which inhabits the relatively small and scarce amber pen-shell Pinna carnea in the tropical Caribbean. In agreement with theory, P. mexicana were found dwelling as heterosexual pairs in the mantle cavity of pen-shell individuals with more frequency than expected by chance alone. However, additional observations suggested that male-female pairing of P. mexicana does not last long. First, males paired with females that were close to molt and become sexually receptive more frequently than expected by chance alone. In monogamous species in which pairing appears to be long lasting, males occur with females in the same host, independent of the reproductive condition of the female. Second, the body size of paired shrimps was poorly correlated and the relationship between host and shrimp body size was weak. If males and females of P. mexicana were staying within host individuals for long periods of time, a tight correlation between host and shrimp size and between males and females in a pair would have been found. Lastly, sexual dimorphism in terms of cheliped size was evident; males invested considerably more resources to this body structure compared to females. In monogamous species in which pairing appears to be long-term, sexual dimorphism is low or absent given that sexual selection is weak in this mating system. Overall, our data suggests that monogamy in P. mexicana does not last long and that males switch among host individuals in search of receptive females. Manipulative experiments are necessary to understand the conditions favoring short- and long-term monogamy in symbiotic crustaceans. (C) 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.