An investigation was carried out on the effectiveness of vegetation management regimes, including one which is commonly used by managers in Selwyn District of the South Island of New Zealand. A neighbourhood study approach with four randomised blocks and eight weed intensity treatments was used. Results from initial measurements and 3 remeasurements showed that there was a strong correlation between the amount of weeds measured and crop tree growth than between treatments and tree growth. Moreover, the conventional control regime (1 m band spraying along tree rows) was shown to lead to suboptimal tree growth. Mean diameter growth under herbaceous competition could be described with a decay function of the form. Y = alpha + beta*exp(-gamma*hpc), while for mean height growth the equation was Y=alpha+beta*exp(hpc); where Y=tree growth, hpc=herbaceous percent cover index and alpha, beta and gamma were estimated non-linear regression coefficients. Under woody competition the function was Y=alpha+beta(wci) for both mean diameter and mean height growth (wci=woody abundance index as expressed by crown foliage density*height*proximity/H). Managers in the area therefore, need to redefine their non-crop vegetation reduction standards so as to improve tree growth and to use available resources more efficiently.