Measuring raw-material criticality of product systems through an economic product importance indicator: a case study of battery-electric vehicles

被引:23
作者
Lutkehaus, Hauke [1 ]
Pade, Christian [1 ]
Oswald, Matthias [1 ]
Brand, Urte [1 ]
Naegler, Tobias [1 ]
Vogt, Thomas [1 ]
机构
[1] German Aerosp Ctr DLR, Inst Networked Energy Syst, Dept Energy Syst Anal, Carl von Ossietzky Str 15, D-26129 Oldenburg, Germany
关键词
Raw-material criticality; Resource criticality; Critical materials; Critical resources; Life cycle assessment; LCA; Life cycle sustainability assessment; LCSA; Substitutability; Battery electric vehicle; BEV; CYCLE SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT; GEOPOLITICAL SUPPLY RISK; IMPACT ASSESSMENT; LIFE; METHODOLOGY; VULNERABILITY; ASSESSMENTS; FRAMEWORK; MINERALS; STATE;
D O I
10.1007/s11367-021-02002-z
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
Purpose The concept of criticality concerns the probability and the possible impacts of shortages in raw-material supply and is usually applied to regional economies or specific industries. With more and more products being highly dependent on potentially critical raw materials, efforts are being made to also incorporate criticality into the framework of life cycle sustainability assessment (LCSA). However, there is still some need for methodological development of indicators to measure raw-material criticality in LCSA. Methods We therefore introduce 'economic product importance' (EPI) as a novel parameter for the product-specific evaluation of the relevance and significance of a certain raw material for a particular product system. We thereby consider both the actual raw-material flows (life cycle inventories) and the life cycle cost. The EPI thus represents a measure for the material-specific product-system vulnerability (another component being the substitutability). Combining the product-system vulnerability of a specific product system towards a certain raw material with the supply disruption probability of that same raw material then yields the product-system specific overall criticality with regard to that raw material. In order to demonstrate our novel approach, we apply it to a case study on a battery-electric vehicle. Results Since our approach accounts for the actual amounts of raw materials used in a product and relates their total share of costs to the overall costs of the product, no under- or over-estimation of the mere presence of the raw materials with respect to their relevance for the product system occurs. Consequently, raw materials, e.g. rare earth elements, which are regularly rated highly critical, do not necessarily reach higher criticality ranks within our approach, if they are either needed in very small amounts only or if their share in total costs of the respective product system is very low. Accordingly, in our case study on a battery-electric vehicle product system, most rare earth elements are ranked less critical than bulk materials such as copper or aluminium. Conclusion Our EPI approach constitutes a step forward towards a methodology for the raw-material criticality assessment within the LCSA framework, mainly because it allows a product-specific evaluation of product-system vulnerability. Furthermore, it is compatible with common methods for the supply disruption probability calculation - such as GeoPolRisk, ESP or ESSENZ - as well as with available substitutability evaluations. The practicability and usefulness of our approach has been shown by applying it to a battery-electric vehicle.
引用
收藏
页码:122 / 137
页数:16
相关论文
共 78 条
[1]   How to evaluate raw material supply risks-an overview [J].
Achzet, Benjamin ;
Helbig, Christoph .
RESOURCES POLICY, 2013, 38 (04) :435-447
[2]   Towards comprehensive assessment of mineral resource availability? Complementary roles of life cycle, life cycle sustainability and criticality assessments [J].
Andre, Hampus ;
Ljunggren, Maria .
RESOURCES CONSERVATION AND RECYCLING, 2021, 167
[3]   Criticality assessment of abiotic resource use for Europe- application of the SCARCE method [J].
Arendt, Rosalie ;
Muhl, Marco ;
Bach, Vanessa ;
Finkbeiner, Matthias .
RESOURCES POLICY, 2020, 67
[4]   Integrated method to assess resource efficiency - ESSENZ [J].
Bach, Vanessa ;
Berger, Markus ;
Henssler, Martin ;
Kirchner, Martin ;
Leiser, Stefan ;
Mohr, Lisa ;
Rother, Elmar ;
Ruhland, Klaus ;
Schneider, Laura ;
Tikana, Ladji ;
Volkhausen, Wolfgang ;
Walachowicz, Frank ;
Finkbeiner, Matthias .
JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION, 2016, 137 :118-130
[5]   Towards life cycle sustainability assessment: drawing on the NEEDS project's total cost and multi-criteria decision analysis ranking methods [J].
Bachmann, Till M. .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT, 2013, 18 (09) :1698-1709
[6]   Prospective cost and environmental impact assessment of battery and fuel cell electric vehicles in Germany [J].
Bekel, Kai ;
Pauliuk, Stefan .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT, 2019, 24 (12) :2220-2237
[7]   The guidelines for social life cycle assessment of products: just in time! [J].
Benoit, Catherine ;
Norris, Gregory A. ;
Valdivia, Sonia ;
Ciroth, Andreas ;
Moberg, Asa ;
Bos, Ulrike ;
Prakash, Siddharth ;
Ugaya, Cassia ;
Beck, Tabea .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT, 2010, 15 (02) :156-163
[8]   Mineral resources in life cycle impact assessment: part II - recommendations on application-dependent use of existing methods and on future method development needs [J].
Berger, Markus ;
Sonderegger, Thomas ;
Alvarenga, Rodrigo ;
Bach, Vanessa ;
Cimprich, Alexander ;
Dewulf, Jo ;
Frischknecht, Rolf ;
Guinee, Jeroen ;
Helbig, Christoph ;
Huppertz, Tom ;
Jolliet, Olivier ;
Motoshita, Masaharu ;
Northey, Stephen ;
Pena, Claudia A. ;
Rugani, Benedetto ;
Sahnoune, Abdelhadi ;
Schrijvers, Dieuwertje ;
Schulze, Rita ;
Sonnemann, Guido ;
Valero, Alicia ;
Weidema, Bo P. ;
Young, Steven B. .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT, 2020, 25 (04) :798-813
[9]   Rare Earths and the Balance Problem: How to Deal with Changing Markets? [J].
Binnemans, Koen ;
Jones, Peter Tom ;
Mueller, Torsten ;
Yurramendi, Lourdes .
JOURNAL OF SUSTAINABLE METALLURGY, 2018, 4 (01) :126-146
[10]   EU methodology for critical raw materials assessment: Policy needs and proposed solutions for incremental improvements [J].
Blengini, Gian Andrea ;
Nuss, Philip ;
Dewulf, Jo ;
Nita, Viorel ;
Peiro, Laura Talens ;
Vidal-Legaz, Beatriz ;
Latunussa, Cynthia ;
Mancini, Lucia ;
Blagoeva, Darina ;
Pennington, David ;
Pellegrini, Mattia ;
Van Maercke, Alexis ;
Solar, Slavko ;
Grohol, Milan ;
Ciupagea, Constantin .
RESOURCES POLICY, 2017, 53 :12-19