Implementation and Evaluation of Quality Improvement Training in Surgery A Systematic Review

被引:3
作者
Pallari, Elena [1 ,2 ]
Khadjesari, Zarnie [1 ,3 ]
Aceituno, David [4 ,5 ,6 ]
Odhiambo, Catherine Anyango [6 ]
Warner, Ross [7 ]
Bastianpillai, Christopher [8 ]
Green, James S. A. [9 ]
Sevdalis, Nick [1 ]
机构
[1] Kings Coll London, Ctr Implementat Sci, Hlth Serv & Populat Res Dept, London, England
[2] UCL, MRC Clin Trials & Methodol, London, England
[3] Univ East Anglia, Sch Hlth Sci, Norwich Res Pk, Norwich, Norfolk, England
[4] Kings Coll London, Hlth Serv & Populat Res Dept, Kings Hlth Econ, London, England
[5] Pontificia Univ Catolica Chile, Med Sch, Dept Psychiat, Santiago, Chile
[6] Kings Coll London, David Goldberg Ctr, Inst Psychiat Psychol & Neurosci IoPPN, Hlth Serv & Populat Res Dept, London, England
[7] Royal Stoke Univ Hosp, Dept Urol, Newcastle Rd, Stoke On Trent, Staffs, England
[8] Northampton Gen Hosp, Dept Urol, Northampton, England
[9] Whipps Cross Hosp & Chest Clin, Dept Urol, Barts NHS Trust, Whipps Cross Rd, London, England
基金
英国经济与社会研究理事会;
关键词
education; effectiveness; implementation science; quality improvement; surgery; systematic review; TEAM-BASED APPROACH; PATIENT SAFETY; CURRICULUM; EDUCATION; RESIDENTS; MEDICINE; PERFORMANCE; SIMULATION; HEALTH; QI;
D O I
10.1097/SLA.0000000000004751
中图分类号
R61 [外科手术学];
学科分类号
摘要
Objective: The of this study was to review and appraise how quality improvement (QI) skills are taught to surgeons and surgical residents. Background: There is a global drive to deliver capacity in undertaking QI within surgical services. However, there are currently no specifications regarding optimal QI content or delivery. Methods: We reviewed QI educational intervention studies targeting surgeons or surgical trainees/residents published until 2017. Primary outcomes included teaching methods and training materials. Secondary outcomes were implementation frameworks and strategies used to deliver QI training successfully. Results: There were 20,590 hits across 10 databases, of which 11,563 were screened following de-duplication. Seventeen studies were included in the final synthesis. Variable QI techniques (eg, combined QI models, process mapping, and "lean" principles) and assessment methods were found. Delivery was more consistent, typically combining didactic teaching blended with QI project delivery. Implementation of QI training was poorly reported and appears supported by collaborative approaches (including building learning collaboratives, and coalitions). Study designs were typically pre-/ post-training without controls. Studies generally lacked clarity on the underpinning framework (59%), setting description (59%), content (47%), and conclusions (47%), whereas 88% scored low on psychometrics reporting. Conclusions: The evidence suggests that surgical QI training can focus on any well-established QI technique, provided it is done through a combination of didactic teaching and practical application. True effectiveness and extent of impact of QI training remain unclear, due to methodological weaknesses and inconsistent reporting. Conduct of larger-scale educational QI studies across multiple institutions can advance the field.
引用
收藏
页码:E489 / E506
页数:18
相关论文
共 91 条
  • [71] Multi-institutional Surgical Education Interventions A Scoping Review
    Salles, Arghavan
    Milam, Laurel
    Sevdalis, Nick
    Alseidi, Adnan
    Mellinger, John
    Stefanidis, Dimitrios
    Nahmias, Jeffry
    Kulaylat, Afif N.
    Kim, Roger H.
    Falcone, John L.
    Arora, Tania K.
    Phitayakorn, Roy
    Cochran, Amalia
    [J]. ANNALS OF SURGERY, 2019, 270 (02) : 257 - 269
  • [72] A randomized, controlled trial of team-based competition to increase learner participation in quality-improvement education
    Scales, Charles D., Jr.
    Moin, Tannaz
    Fink, Arlene
    Berry, Sandra H.
    Afsar-Manesh, Nasim
    Mangione, Carol M.
    Kerfoot, B. Price
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR QUALITY IN HEALTH CARE, 2016, 28 (02) : 227 - 232
  • [73] American College of Surgeons NSQIP: Quality In-Training Initiative Pilot Study
    Sellers, Morgan M.
    Reinke, Caroline E.
    Kreider, Susan
    Meise, Chelsey
    Nelis, Kara
    Volpe, Anita
    Anzlovar, Nancy
    Ko, Clifford
    Kelz, Rachel R.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF SURGEONS, 2013, 217 (05) : 827 - 832
  • [74] Development and Participant Assessment of a Practical Quality Improvement Educational Initiative for Surgical Residents
    Sellers, Morgan M.
    Hanson, Kristi
    Schuller, Mary
    Sherman, Karen
    Kelz, Rachel R.
    Fryer, Jonathan
    DaRosa, Debra
    Bilimoria, Karl Y.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF SURGEONS, 2013, 216 (06) : 1207 - +
  • [75] Sepulveda Debra, 2012, J Grad Med Educ, V4, P237, DOI 10.4300/JGME-D-11-00158.1
  • [76] Quality education: A pilot quality improvement curriculum for psychiatry residents
    Sockalingam, Sanjeev
    Stergiopoulos, Vicky
    Maggi, Julie
    Zaretsky, Ari
    [J]. MEDICAL TEACHER, 2010, 32 (05) : E221 - E226
  • [77] Quality Improvement (QI) Education in a Psychiatry Residency Program: "Diagnosis and Consultation" as Key QI Skills
    Stagno, Susan J.
    Cheren, Mark
    [J]. ACADEMIC PSYCHIATRY, 2014, 38 (04) : 502 - 505
  • [78] Simulation in Surgery What's Needed Next?
    Stefanidis, Dimitrios
    Sevdalis, Nick
    Paige, John
    Zevin, Boris
    Aggarwal, Rajesh
    Grantcharov, Teodor
    Jones, Daniel B.
    [J]. ANNALS OF SURGERY, 2015, 261 (05) : 846 - 853
  • [79] A NOVEL PROGRAM TO IMPROVE PATIENT SAFETY BY INTEGRATING PEER REVIEW INTO THE EMERGENCY MEDICINE RESIDENCY CURRICULUM
    Strayer, Reuben J.
    Shy, Bradley D.
    Shearer, Peter L.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 2014, 47 (06) : 696 - U200
  • [80] Surgical simulation - A systematic review
    Sutherland, LM
    Middleton, PF
    Anthony, A
    Hamdorf, J
    Cregan, P
    Scott, D
    Maddern, GJ
    [J]. ANNALS OF SURGERY, 2006, 243 (03) : 291 - 300