Quantitative Assessment of Ophthalmic Viscosurgical Devices on Visibility, Spreadability, and Durability as Corneal Wetting Agents for the Wet Shell Technique

Purpose To evaluate ophthalmic viscosurgical devices (OVDs) as corneal wetting agents for the wet shell technique, a common procedure in Japan to maintain the wettability of corneal surfaces. Methods We surveyed Japanese ophthalmologists to determine the current state of the wet shell technique. After developing three ex vivo testing methods, we evaluated the corneal wetting properties of OVDs including 3% hyaluronic acid (HA) solution and OVD products, Opegan, Opelead, Viscoat, Shellgan, Discovisc, and Opegan-Hi. Results Overall, 214 ophthalmologists (70%) had performed the wet shell technique, and 91% of ophthalmologists who performed vitreous surgery had performed this technique. Using a questionnaire, we evaluated the performance of OVD as corneal wetting agents as follows: (i) visibility, smoothness of OVD surface; (ii) spreadability, coverage of the cornea; and (iii) retention durability, residual ratio of OVD on the corneal surface. The smoothness and spreadability of Opegan, Opelead, and 3% HA were superior to other OVDs. Adding an appropriate amount of balanced salt solution to the other OVDs improved smoothness and spreadability similar to that of Opelead or 3% HA. Shellgan and Viscoat, combination OVDs consisting of 3% HA and 4% chondroitin sulfate, showed high retention durability, resulting in remaining longer on the cornea compared with other OVDs. Conclusions Physical properties of OVDs tested in this study may provide useful information for ophthalmologists to select a suitable OVD when performing the wet shell technique.