Importance of sperm-binding assays for fertility prognosis of porcine spermatozoa

There has been a considerable effort to establish correlations between the outcome of in vitro sperm-binding assays and the fertility achieved by individual males under conditions of commercial AI. During passage through the oviduct, a fertilizing spermatozoon has to bind to and interact with several targets. Generally, it is assumed that these interactions can be mimicked by in vitro binding assays. However, there is little evidence that assays based on zona binding, zona penetration, or IVF: (a) have been adequately validated; (b) provide data with a high degree of correlation to a boar of average fertility; (c) provide accurate predictions as to pregnancy rate and litter size from a given boar when used for commercial AI. This is due partly to the variability in measurements of pregnancy rate and litter size in a commercial setting and partly to the fact that sperm fertility is multifactorial. A recently developed in vitro test is based on the fact that spermatozoa bind in vivo to oviduct epithelium, creating a functional sperm reservoir, and that fertilization-competent spermatozoa are released in a time-dependent manner from these cells. Mating or insemination occurs usually hours before ovulation thus rendering such temporary sperm binding to the epithelial cells, a prerequisite for successful sperm-oocyte interaction. In vitro binding of porcine spermatozoa to explants derived from fresh oviduct epithelium may provide a useful test system to predict fertility, although detailed validation has not been published. The sperm-oviduct-binding assay tests for multifunctional characteristics of the plasma membrane and may be a valuable in vitro test to identify subfertile boars. We believe that boar subfertility might be indicated in vitro by reduced capacity of his spermatozoa to bind to oviductal cells and that this may provide information as to whether an adequate sperm reservoir will presumably be established in vivo from the sperm population that successfully has passed the barriers of the utero-tubal junction. (C) 2004 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.