Evaluation of a Standardized CT Colonography Training Program for Novice Readers

被引:45
作者
Liedenbaum, Marjolein H. [1 ]
Bipat, Shandra [1 ]
Bossuyt, Patrick M. M. [2 ]
Dwarkasing, Roy S. [3 ]
de Haan, Margriet C. [1 ]
Jansen, Roel J. [1 ]
Kauffman, Dominique [1 ]
van der Leij, Christiaan [1 ]
de Lijster, Manou S. [1 ]
Lute, Cindy C. [1 ]
van der Paardt, Marije P. [1 ]
Thomeer, Maarten G. [3 ]
Zijlstra, IJsbrand A. [1 ]
Stoker, Jaap [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Amsterdam, Acad Med Ctr Amsterdam, Dept Radiol, NL-1105 AZ Amsterdam, Netherlands
[2] Univ Amsterdam, Acad Med Ctr Amsterdam, Dept Clin Epidemiol & Biostat, NL-1105 AZ Amsterdam, Netherlands
[3] Univ Med Ctr, Erasmus MC, Dept Radiol, Rotterdam, Netherlands
关键词
CONTRAST BARIUM ENEMA; EXPERIENCED READERS; COLORECTAL-CANCER; PERFORMANCE; MULTICENTER; POLYPS; ERRORS; TIMES;
D O I
10.1148/radiol.10100019
中图分类号
R8 [特种医学]; R445 [影像诊断学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100207 ; 1009 ;
摘要
Purpose: To determine how many computed tomographic (CT) colonography training studies have to be evaluated by novice readers to obtain an adequate level of competence in polyp detection. Materials and Methods: The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board. Informed consent was obtained from all participants. Six physicians (one radiologist, three radiology residents, two researchers) and three technicians completed a CT colonography training program. Two hundred CT colonographic examinations with colonoscopic verification were selected from a research database, with 100 CT colonographic examinations with at least one polyp 6 mm or larger. After a lecture session and short individual hands-on training, CT colonography training was done individually with immediate feedback of colonoscopy outcome. Per-polyp sensitivity was calculated for four sets of 50 CT colonographic examinations for lesions 6 mm or larger. By using logistic regression analyses, the number of CT colonographic examinations to reach 90% sensitivity for lesions 6 mm or larger was estimated. Reading times were registered. Results: The average per-polyp sensitivity for lesions 6 mm or larger was 76% (207 of 270) in the first set of 50 CT colonographic examinations, 77% (262 of 342) in the second (P = .96 vs first set), 80% (310 of 387) in the third (P = .67 vs first set), and 91% (261 of 288) in the fourth (P = .018). The estimated number of CT colonographic examinations for a sufficient sensitivity was 164. Six of nine readers reached this level of competence within 175 CT colonographic examinations. Reading times decreased significantly from the first to the second set of 50 CT colonographic examinations for six readers. Conclusion: Novice CT colonography readers obtained sensitivity equal to that of experienced readers after practicing on average 164 CT colonographic studies. (C)RSNA, 2010
引用
收藏
页码:477 / 487
页数:11
相关论文
共 28 条
[1]   Nonradiologists as second readers for intraluminal findings at CT colonography [J].
Bodily, KD ;
Fletcher, JG ;
Engelby, T ;
Percival, M ;
Christensen, JA ;
Young, B ;
Krych, AJ ;
Kooi, DCV ;
Rodysill, D ;
Fidler, JL ;
Johnson, CD .
ACADEMIC RADIOLOGY, 2005, 12 (01) :67-73
[2]   CT colonography standards [J].
Burling, D. .
CLINICAL RADIOLOGY, 2010, 65 (06) :474-480
[3]   CT colonography interpretation times: effect of reader experience, fatigue, and scan findings in a multi-centre setting [J].
Burling, David ;
Halligan, Steve ;
Altman, Douglas G. ;
Atkin, Wendy ;
Bartram, Clive ;
Fenlon, Helen ;
Laghi, Andrea ;
Stoker, Jaap ;
Taylor, Stuart ;
Frost, Roger ;
Dessey, Guido ;
De Villiers, Melinda ;
Florie, Jasper ;
Foley, Shane ;
Honeyfield, Lesley ;
Iannaccone, Riccardo ;
Gallo, Teresa ;
Kay, Clive ;
Lefere, Philippe ;
Lowe, Andrew ;
Mangiapane, Filipo ;
Marrannes, Jesse ;
Neri, Emmanuele ;
Nieddu, Giulia ;
Nicholson, David ;
O'Hare, Alan ;
Ori, Sante ;
Politi, Benedetta ;
Poulus, Martin ;
Regge, Daniele ;
Renaut, Lisa ;
Rudralingham, Velauthan ;
Signoretta, Saverio ;
Vagli, Paola ;
Van der Hulst, Victor ;
Williams-Butt, Jane .
EUROPEAN RADIOLOGY, 2006, 16 (08) :1745-1749
[4]   Formative evaluation of standardized training for CT colonographic image interpretation by novice readers [J].
Dachman, Abraham H. ;
Kelly, Katherine B. ;
Zintsmaster, Michael P. ;
Rana, Rich ;
Khankari, Shweta ;
Novak, Joseph D. ;
Ali, Arif N. ;
Qalbani, Adnan ;
Fletcher, Joel G. .
RADIOLOGY, 2008, 249 (01) :167-177
[5]   Primary uncleansed 2D versus primary electronically cleansed 3D in limited bowel preparation CT-colonography. Is there a difference for novices and experienced readers? [J].
de Vries, Ayso H. ;
Liedenbaum, Marjolein H. ;
Bipat, Shandra ;
Truyen, Roel ;
Serlie, Iwo W. O. ;
Cohen, Rutger H. ;
van Elderen, Saskia G. C. ;
Heutinck, Anneke ;
Kesselring, Oskar ;
de Monye, Wouter ;
te Strake, Lambertus ;
Wiersma, Tjeerd ;
Stoker, Jaap .
EUROPEAN RADIOLOGY, 2009, 19 (08) :1939-1950
[6]   Double-contrast barium enema: Use in practice and implications for CT colonography [J].
Ferrucci, Joseph T. .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF ROENTGENOLOGY, 2006, 187 (01) :170-173
[7]   Understanding interpretive errors in radiologists learning computed tomography colonography [J].
Fidler, JL ;
Fletcher, JG ;
Johnson, CD ;
Huprich, JE ;
Barlow, JM ;
Earnest, F ;
Bartholmai, BJ .
ACADEMIC RADIOLOGY, 2004, 11 (07) :750-756
[8]   Effect of investigator experience in CT colonography [J].
Gluecker, T ;
Meuwly, JY ;
Pescatore, P ;
Schnyder, P ;
Delarive, J ;
Jornod, P ;
Meuli, R ;
Dorta, G .
EUROPEAN RADIOLOGY, 2002, 12 (06) :1405-1409
[9]   Effect of directed training on reader performance for CT colonography: Multicenter study [J].
Halligan, Steve ;
Burling, David ;
Atkin, Wendy ;
Bartram, Clive ;
Fenlon, Helen ;
Laghi, Andrea ;
Stoker, Jaap ;
Altman, Douglas G. ;
Bassett, Paul ;
Frost, Roger ;
Taylor, Stuart ;
Bartram, Clive ;
Honeyfield, Lesley ;
De Villiers, Melinda ;
Nicholson, David ;
Renaut, Lisa ;
Kay, Clive ;
Lowe, Andy ;
Williams-Butt, Jane ;
Florie, Jasper ;
Poulus, Martin ;
Van der Hulst, Victor ;
Lefere, Philippe ;
Marrannes, Jesse ;
Dessey, Guido ;
Fenlon, Helen ;
O'Hare, Alan ;
Foley, Shane ;
Neri, Emmanuele ;
Vagli, Paola ;
Politi, Benedetta ;
Iannaccone, Riccardo ;
Mangiapane, Filipo ;
Ori, Sante ;
Gallo, Teresa ;
Nieddu, Giulia ;
Signoretta, Saverio ;
Regge, Daniele .
RADIOLOGY, 2007, 242 (01) :152-161
[10]   Virtual dissection CT colonography: Evaluation of learning curves and reading times with and without computer-aided detection [J].
Hock, Danielle ;
Ouhadi, Roxanne ;
Materne, Roland ;
Aouchria, Amir-Samy ;
Mancini, Isabelle ;
Broussaud, Thomas ;
Magotteaux, Paul ;
Nchimi, Alain .
RADIOLOGY, 2008, 248 (03) :860-868