Individualized therapy trials: navigating patient care, research goals and ethics

被引:18
作者
Kane, Patrick Bodilly [1 ]
Bittlinger, Merlin [1 ]
Kimmelman, Jonathan [1 ]
机构
[1] McGill Univ, Biomed Eth Unit, Studies Translat Eth & Med, Montreal, PQ, Canada
关键词
ESTIMATE POPULATION TREATMENT; DEEP BRAIN-STIMULATION; N-OF-1; TRIALS; RANDOMIZED TRIALS; ONCOLOGY TRIALS; INTERVENTIONS; INFORMATION; EQUIPOISE; QUALITY; BENEFIT;
D O I
10.1038/s41591-021-01519-y
中图分类号
Q5 [生物化学]; Q7 [分子生物学];
学科分类号
071010 ; 081704 ;
摘要
'Individualized therapy' trials (sometimes called n-of-1 trials) use patients as their own controls to evaluate treatments. Here we divide such trials into three categories: multi-crossover trials aimed at individual patient management, multi-crossover trial series and pre-post trials. These trials all customize interventions for patients; however, the latter two categories also aim to inform medical practice and thus embody tensions between the goals of care and research that are typical of other types of clinical trials. In this Perspective, we discuss four domains where such tensions play out-clinical equipoise, informed consent, reporting and funding, and we provide recommendations for addressing each. In this Perspective, the authors discuss the ethical challenges of individualized therapy (also called n-of-1) trials and argue that, although customized for the patient, these constitute 'research' nonetheless.
引用
收藏
页码:1679 / 1686
页数:8
相关论文
共 92 条
  • [1] Extending Clinical Equipoise to Phase 1 Trials Involving Patients: Unresolved Problems
    Anderson, James A.
    Kimmelman, Jonathan
    [J]. KENNEDY INSTITUTE OF ETHICS JOURNAL, 2010, 20 (01) : 75 - 98
  • [2] The cost of getting personal
    不详
    [J]. NATURE MEDICINE, 2019, 25 (12) : 1797 - 1797
  • [3] [Anonymous], 2014, Examination of Clinical Trial Costs and Barriers for Drug Development
  • [4] FALSE HOPES AND BEST DATA - CONSENT TO RESEARCH AND THE THERAPEUTIC MISCONCEPTION
    APPELBAUM, PS
    ROTH, LH
    LIDZ, CW
    BENSON, P
    WINSLADE, W
    [J]. HASTINGS CENTER REPORT, 1987, 17 (02) : 20 - 24
  • [5] Understanding Variation in Sets of N-of-1 Trials
    Araujo, Artur
    Julious, Steven
    Senn, Stephen
    [J]. PLOS ONE, 2016, 11 (12):
  • [6] Multicrossover Randomized Controlled Trial Designs in Alzheimer Disease
    Arnold, Steven E.
    Betensky, Rebecca A.
    [J]. ANNALS OF NEUROLOGY, 2018, 84 (02) : 168 - 175
  • [7] N-of-1 clinical trials should be incorporated into clinical practice
    Berlin, Jesse A.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2010, 63 (12) : 1283 - 1284
  • [8] Impediments to Effective Altruism: The Role of Subjective Preferences in Charitable Giving
    Berman, Jonathan Z.
    Barasch, Alixandra
    Levine, Emma E.
    Small, Deborah A.
    [J]. PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE, 2018, 29 (05) : 834 - 844
  • [9] Comparison of Aggregated N-of-1 Trials with Parallel and Crossover Randomized Controlled Trials Using Simulation Studies
    Blackston, J. Walker
    Chapple, Andrew G.
    McGree, James M.
    McDonald, Suzanne
    Nikles, Jane
    [J]. HEALTHCARE, 2019, 7 (04) : 1 - 13
  • [10] Compassionate and innovative treatments in children: a proposal for an ethical framework
    Brierley, Joe
    Larcher, Vic
    [J]. ARCHIVES OF DISEASE IN CHILDHOOD, 2009, 94 (09) : 651 - 654