Acceptance of and attitude toward genetic testing for hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer:: A comparison of participants and nonparticipants in genetic counseling

PURPOSE: Data on the actual uptake of genetic testing for hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC) in a clinical sample is still inconclusive. The present study aimed to define the actual uptake of genetic counseling and testing offered to an unselected sample of 140 patients with colorectal cancer, fulfilling clinical criteria (Amsterdam or Bethesda) suggestive of HNPCC, and to identify demographic and psychosocial factors associated with the decision to participate in counseling. METHODS: Cross-sectional survey. Eligible subjects had been consecutively enrolled in a regional tumor registry between 1994 and 1998, and were invited to attend an information session for HNPCC at the time genetic testing for HNPCC became available. Participants and nonparticipants in the information session completed a short questionnaire. RESULTS: The actual uptake rate of the information session in this sample was 26 percent. Participants and nonparticipants were comparable with regard to clinical criteria suggestive of HNPCC, awareness of the potential hereditary predisposition, and previous history of cancer in the family. Some 60 percent of participants experienced pronounced distress related to their potential inheritance of the disorder, compared to 35 percent among nonparticipants. Distress reached a clinically significant level in 28 percent of participants. Restricted communication within the family was observed frequently. Irrespective of groups, a positive attitude toward obtaining a gene test result predominated. CONCLUSIONS: Results suggest that expressed intention and attitude toward genetic testing do not reliably predict actual uptake of counseling or testing. Thorough interdisciplinary counseling should be provided to every patient with clinical criteria suggestive of HNPCC. The considerable distress related to the hereditary disorder should be adequately addressed, as should be communication issues.