Can we trust measures of healthcare utilization from household surveys?

被引:26
作者
Ansah, Evelyn Korkor [1 ]
Powell-Jackson, Timothy [2 ]
机构
[1] Ghana Hlth Serv, Res & Dev Div, Accra, Ghana
[2] London Sch Hyg & Trop Med, Dept Global Hlth & Dev, London WC1H 9SH, England
基金
比尔及梅琳达.盖茨基金会;
关键词
Pictorial diary; Healthcare utilization; Recall periods; Health surveys; REPORTED MORBIDITY; COLLECTION; EVENTS; IMPACT; DIARY;
D O I
10.1186/1471-2458-13-853
中图分类号
R1 [预防医学、卫生学];
学科分类号
1004 ; 120402 ;
摘要
Background: The research community relies heavily on measures of healthcare utilization from household surveys to understand health seeking choices and to evaluate interventions in developing countries. Such measures are known to suffer from recall problems but there is limited evidence of whether the method of data collection affects evaluation findings. We compared the results of a randomized trial of free healthcare using utilization data from two sources. Methods: Data are from a study in Ghana, in which 2,194 households containing 2,592 children under 5 y old were randomized into a prepayment scheme providing free primary and some referral care, or to a control group whose families paid user fees for healthcare. Data on morbidity and health seeking behaviour were collected using a standard household survey administered at endline and a pictorial diary given to households over a six month period, collected at monthly intervals. Results: Self-reported measures of morbidity and healthcare utilization were substantially lower in the household survey than the pictorial diary when the recall period was over a month. Introducing free healthcare had a positive effect on primary care visits based on the pictorial diary and a non-significant negative effect according to the household survey. Using any clinic visit in the past month as the outcome, the difference in the effect of free care between the two data collection methods was 3.6 percentage points (p = 0.078). Conclusions: The findings raise methodological concerns about measures of healthcare utilization from household surveys, particularly in the evaluation of health financing interventions.
引用
收藏
页数:8
相关论文
共 26 条
[1]   Effect of Removing Direct Payment for Health Care on Utilisation and Health Outcomes in Ghanaian Children: A Randomised Controlled Trial [J].
Ansah, Evelyn Korkor ;
Narh-Bana, Solomon ;
Asiamah, Sabina ;
Dzordzordzi, Vivian ;
Biantey, Kingsley ;
Dickson, Kakra ;
Gyapong, John Owusu ;
Koram, Kwadwo Ansah ;
Greenwood, Brian M. ;
Mills, Anne ;
Whitty, Christopher J. M. .
PLOS MEDICINE, 2009, 6 (01) :48-58
[2]   Optimal Recall Period for Caregiver-reported Illness in Risk Factor and Intervention Studies: A Multicountry Study [J].
Arnold, Benjamin F. ;
Galiani, Sebastian ;
Ram, Pavani K. ;
Hubbard, Alan E. ;
Briceno, Bertha ;
Gertler, Paul J. ;
Colford, John M., Jr. .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2013, 177 (04) :361-370
[3]   New evidence on the impact of China's New Rural Cooperative Medical Scheme and its implications for rural primary healthcare: multivariate difference-in-difference analysis [J].
Babiarz, Kimberly Singer ;
Miller, Grant ;
Yi, Hongmei ;
Zhang, Linxiu ;
Rozelle, Scott .
BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2010, 341 :929
[4]  
Cannell C.F., 1977, SUMMARY STUDIES INTE
[5]  
Coxon A., 1994, Challenge and Innovation: Methodologi cal Advances in Social Research on HIV/AIDS
[6]   The impact of recall periods on reported morbidity and health seeking behavior [J].
Das, Jishnu ;
Hammer, Jeffrey ;
Sanchez-Paramo, Carolina .
JOURNAL OF DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS, 2012, 98 (01) :76-88
[7]   Daily data collection of sexual and other health-related behaviors [J].
Gillmore, MR ;
Gaylord, J ;
Hartway, J ;
Hoppe, MJ ;
Morrison, DM ;
Leigh, BC ;
Rainey, DT .
JOURNAL OF SEX RESEARCH, 2001, 38 (01) :35-42
[8]   CONVINCING EVIDENCE FROM CONTROLLED AND UNCONTROLLED STUDIES ON THE LIPID-LOWERING EFFECT OF A STATIN [J].
Higgins, Julian .
COCHRANE DATABASE OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS, 2012, (12)
[9]   VALIDITY OF QUESTIONNAIRE INFORMATION ON FREQUENCY OF COITUS [J].
HORNSBY, PP ;
WILCOX, AJ .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY, 1989, 130 (01) :94-99
[10]   Public policy for the poor? A randomised assessment of the Mexican universal health insurance programme [J].
King, Gary ;
Gakidou, Emmanuela ;
Imai, Kosuke ;
Lakin, Jason ;
Moore, Ryan T. ;
Nall, Clayton ;
Ravishankar, Nirmala ;
Vargas, Manett ;
Maria Tellez-Rojo, Martha ;
Hernandez Avila, Juan Eugenio ;
Hernandez Avila, Mauricio ;
Hernandez Llamas, Hector .
LANCET, 2009, 373 (9673) :1447-1454