No difference in mortality among ALPPS, two-staged hepatectomy, and portal vein embolization/ligation: A systematic review by updated traditional and network meta-analyses

Background: There is an ongoing debate on the feasibility, safety, and oncological efficacy of the associating liver partition and portal vein ligation for staged hepatectomy (ALPPS) technique. The aim of this study was to compare ALPPS, two-staged hepatectomy (TSH), and portal vein embolization (PVE)/ligation (PVL) using updated traditional meta-analysis and network meta-analysis (NMA). Data sources: Electronic databases were used in a systematic literature search. Updated traditional meta-analysis and NMA were performed and compared. Mortality and major morbidity were selected as primary outcomes. Results: Nineteen studies including 1200 patients were selected from the pool of 436 studies. Of these patients, 315 (31%) and 702 (69%) underwent ALPPS and portal vein occlusion (PVO), respectively. Ninetyday mortality based on updated traditional meta-analysis, subgroup analysis of the randomized controlled trials (RCTs), and both Bayesian and frequentist NMA did not demonstrate significant differences between the ALPPS cohort and the PVE, PVL, and TSH cohorts. Moreover, analysis of RCTs did not demonstrate significant differences of major morbidity between the ALPPS and PVO cohorts. The ALPPS cohort demonstrated significantly more favorable outcomes in hypertrophy parameters, time to operation, definitive hepatectomy, and R0 margins rates compared with the PVO cohort. In contrast, 1-year disease-free survival was significantly higher in the PVO cohort compared to the ALPPS cohort. Conclusions: This study is the first to use updated traditional meta-analysis and both Bayesian and frequentist NMA and demonstrated no significant differences in 90-day mortality between the ALPPS and other hepatic hypertrophy approaches. Furthermore, two high quality RCTs including 147 patients demonstrated no significant differences in major morbidity between the ALPPS and PVO cohorts. (c) 2020 First Affiliated Hospital, Zhejiang University School of Medicine in China. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.