Semantic subordination despite syntactic coordination

被引:9
作者
Culicover, PW
Jackendoff, R
机构
[1] OHIO STATE UNIV,CTR COGNIT SCI,COLUMBUS,OH 43210
[2] BRANDEIS UNIV,PROGRAM LINGUIST & COGNIT SCI,WALTHAM,MA 02254
关键词
coordination; subordination; correspondence rules; conceptual structure; syntactic constraints;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
H0 [语言学];
学科分类号
030303 ; 0501 ; 050102 ;
摘要
In several respects, including binding and quantification, the left-hand conjunct in ''left-subordinating'' and-constructions (e.g., you drink one more can of beer and I'm leaving) behaves like a subordinate clause. However, treating it as syntactically subordinate results in an unnatural account of its superficially coordinate structure. Thus, the binding and quantification effects must be due to subordination at the level of conceptual structure, not syntactic structure. In addition, certain extraction and inversion phenomena in the left-hand clause are consistent only with its being coordinated in syntactic structure. A striking consequence is that the Coordinate Structure Constraint holds at conceptual structure, whereas Condition on Extraction Domain effects are strictly syntactic. The left-subordinating and-construction is thus another example of a significant mismatch between syntactic structure and semantic representation.
引用
收藏
页码:195 / 217
页数:23
相关论文
共 28 条
  • [1] Barss Andrew, 1986, THESIS MIT CAMBRIDGE
  • [2] CHIERCHIA G, 1995, DYNAMICS MEANINGS AN
  • [3] CINQUE G, 1990, TYPES DEPENDENCIES
  • [4] CULICOVER P, 1970, LINGUIST INQ, V1, P366
  • [5] CULICOVER PW, 1992, LINGUIST INQ, V23, P659
  • [6] CULICOVER PW, 1995, LINGUIST INQ, V26, P249
  • [7] CULICOVER PW, 1972, FOUND LANG, V8, P199
  • [8] Deane PaulD., 1992, Grammar in Mind and Brain: Explorations in Cognitive Syntax
  • [9] Fauconnier Gilles, 1985, MENTAL SPACES
  • [10] REGULARITY AND IDIOMATICITY IN GRAMMATICAL CONSTRUCTIONS - THE CASE OF LET ALONE
    FILLMORE, CJ
    KAY, P
    OCONNOR, MC
    [J]. LANGUAGE, 1988, 64 (03) : 501 - 538