Isocratic and gradient impedance plot analysis and comparison of some recently introduced large size core-shell and fully porous particles

The intrinsic kinetic performance of three recently commercialized large size (>= 4 mu m) core-shell particles packed in columns with different lengths has been measured and compared with that of standard fully porous particles of similar and smaller size (5 and 3.5 mu m, respectively). The kinetic performance is compared in both absolute (plot of t(0) versus the plate count N or the peak capacity n(p) for isocratic and gradient elution, respectively) and dimensionless units. The latter is realized by switching to so-called impedance plots, a format which has been previously introduced (as a plot of t(0)/N-2 or E-0 versus N-opt/N) and has in the present study been extended from isocratic to gradient elution (where the impedance plot corresponds to a plot of t(0)/n(p)(4) versus n(p,opt)(2)/n(p)(2)). Both the isocratic and gradient impedance plot yielded a very similar picture: the clustered impedance plot curves divide into two distinct groups, one for the core-shell particles (lowest values, i.e. best performance) and one for the fully porous particles (highest values), confirming the clear intrinsic kinetic advantage of core-shell particles. If used around their optimal flow rate, the core-shell particles displayed a minimal separation impedance that is about 40% lower than the fully porous particles. Even larger gains in separation speed can be achieved in the C-term regime. (C) 2013 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.