Comparison of Two In Vitro Extraction Protocols for Assessing Metals' Bioaccessibility Using Dust and Soil Reference Materials

The bioaccessibility of arsenic, cadmium, chromium, copper, lead, nickel, and zinc in four National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) standard reference materials and two Canadian dust samples as determined using the Solubility/Bioavailability Research Consortium (SBRC) in vitro procedure ranged from a low of 1.8% for chromium in standard reference material NIST 2711 to a high of 95.2% for cadmium in NIST 2584. The SBRC data were compared to data generated using a modified EN-71 Toy Safety protocol conducted at two different laboratories. Results for the two extraction methods compared well with differences between the means (SBRC vs. modified EN-71) generally less than 10% for the majority of the metals. These differences between the two extraction methods were negligible compared to variability caused by (a) the inherent heterogeneity of typical house dust samples and (b) differences in ICP-MS analytical approaches employed in the different laboratories. Results indicate that the modified EN-71 method is useful and appropriate as a relatively simple, rapid, and reproducible screening test for estimating metals' bioaccessibility in soil and dust samples.