The effect of coronary calcification on diagnostic performance of machine learning-based CT-FFR: a Chinese multicenter study

被引:34
作者
Di Jiang, Meng [1 ]
Zhang, Xiao Lei [1 ]
Liu, Hui [2 ]
Tang, Chun Xiang [1 ]
Li, Jian Hua [3 ]
Wang, Yi Ning [4 ]
Xu, Peng Peng [1 ]
Zhou, Chang Sheng [1 ]
Zhou, Fan [1 ]
Lu, Meng Jie [1 ]
Zhang, Jia Yin [5 ,6 ]
Yu, Meng Meng [5 ,6 ]
Hou, Yang [7 ]
Zheng, Min Wen [8 ]
Zhang, Bo [9 ]
Zhang, Dai Min [10 ]
Yi, Yan [5 ,6 ]
Xu, Lei [11 ]
Hu, Xiu Hua [12 ]
Yang, Jian [13 ]
Lu, Guang Ming [1 ]
Ni, Qian Qian [1 ]
Zhang, Long Jiang [1 ]
机构
[1] Nanjing Univ, Dept Med Imaging, Jinling Hosp, Med Sch, Nanjing 210002, Jiangsu, Peoples R China
[2] Guangdong Gen Hosp, Dept Radiol, Guangzhou 510080, Peoples R China
[3] Nanjing Univ, Jinling Hosp, Med Sch, Dept Cardiol, Nanjing 210002, Jiangsu, Peoples R China
[4] Chinese Acad Med Sci & Peking Union Med Coll, Peking Union Med Coll Hosp, Dept Radiol, Beijing 100730, Peoples R China
[5] Shanghai Jiao Tong Univ Affiliated Peoples Hosp 6, Inst Diagnost & Intervent Radiol, Shanghai 200233, Peoples R China
[6] Shanghai Jiao Tong Univ Affiliated Peoples Hosp 6, Dept Cardiol, Shanghai 200233, Peoples R China
[7] China Med Univ, Shengjing Hosp, Dept Radiol, Shenyang 110001, Peoples R China
[8] Fourth Mil Med Univ, Xijing Hosp, Dept Radiol, Xian, Shanxi, Peoples R China
[9] Jiangsu Taizhou Peoples Hosp, Dept Radiol, Taizhou 225300, Peoples R China
[10] Nanjing Med Univ, Nanjing Hosp 1, Dept Cardiol, Nanjing 210006, Jiangsu, Peoples R China
[11] Capital Med Univ, Beijing Anzhen Hosp, Dept Radiol, Beijing 10029, Peoples R China
[12] Zhejiang Univ, Shaoyifu Hosp, Med Coll, Dept Radiol, Hangzhou 310016, Peoples R China
[13] Xi An Jiao Tong Univ, Med Sch, Affiliated Hosp 1, Dept Radiol, Xian 710061, Peoples R China
基金
中国国家自然科学基金;
关键词
Computed tomography angiography; Coronary disease; Calcium; Ischemia; Data accuracy; FRACTIONAL FLOW RESERVE; COMPUTED-TOMOGRAPHY; ARTERY-DISEASE; ANGIOGRAPHY; ACCURACY; STENOSIS; LESIONS; SCORE;
D O I
10.1007/s00330-020-07261-2
中图分类号
R8 [特种医学]; R445 [影像诊断学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100207 ; 1009 ;
摘要
Objective To investigate the effect of coronary calcification morphology and severity on the diagnostic performance of machine learning (ML)-based coronary CT angiography (CCTA)-derived fractional flow reserve (CT-FFR) with FFR as a reference standard. Methods A total of 442 patients (61.2 +/- 9.1 years, 70% men) with 544 vessels who underwent CCTA, ML-based CT-FFR, and invasive FFR from China multicenter CT-FFR study were enrolled. The effect of calcification arc, calcification remodeling index (CRI), and Agatston score (AS) on the diagnostic performance of CT-FFR was investigated. CT-FFR <= 0.80 and lumen reduction >= 50% determined by CCTA were identified as vessel-specific ischemia with invasive FFR as a reference standard. Results Compared with invasive FFR, ML-based CT-FFR yielded an overall sensitivity of 0.84, specificity of 0.94, and accuracy of 0.90 in a total of 344 calcification lesions. There was no statistical difference in diagnostic accuracy, sensitivity, or specificity of CT-FFR across different calcification arc, CRI, or AS levels. CT-FFR exhibited improved discrimination of ischemia compared with CCTA alone in lesions with mild-to-moderate calcification (AUC, 0.89 vs. 0.69,p< 0.001) and lesions with CRI >= 1 (AUC, 0.89 vs. 0.71,p< 0.001). The diagnostic accuracy and specificity of CT-FFR were higher than CCTA alone in patients and vessels with mid (100 to 299) or high (>= 300) AS. Conclusion Coronary calcification morphology and severity did not influence diagnostic performance of CT-FFR in ischemia detection, and CT-FFR showed marked improved discrimination of ischemia compared with CCTA alone in the setting of calcification.
引用
收藏
页码:1482 / 1493
页数:12
相关论文
共 36 条
[1]   QUANTIFICATION OF CORONARY-ARTERY CALCIUM USING ULTRAFAST COMPUTED-TOMOGRAPHY [J].
AGATSTON, AS ;
JANOWITZ, WR ;
HILDNER, FJ ;
ZUSMER, NR ;
VIAMONTE, M ;
DETRANO, R .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY, 1990, 15 (04) :827-832
[2]   Impact of Fractional Flow Reserve Derived From Coronary Computed Tomography Angiography on Heart Team Treatment Decision-Making in Patients With Multivessel Coronary Artery Disease Insights From the SYNTAX III REVOLUTION Trial [J].
Andreini, Daniele ;
Modolo, Rodrigo ;
Katagiri, Yuki ;
Mushtaq, Saima ;
Sonck, Jeroen ;
Collet, Carlos ;
De Martini, Stefano ;
Roberto, Maurizio ;
Tanaka, Kaoru ;
Miyazaki, Yosuke ;
Czapla, Jens ;
Schoors, Danny ;
Plass, Andre ;
Maisano, Francesco ;
Kaufmann, Philipp ;
Orry, Xavier ;
Metzdorf, Pierre-Adrien ;
Folliguet, Thierry ;
Faerber, Gloria ;
Diamantis, Ioannis ;
Schoenweiss, Marc ;
Bonalumi, Giorgia ;
Guglielmo, Marco ;
Ferrari, Cristina ;
Olivares, Paolo ;
Cavallotti, Laura ;
Leal, Ingrid ;
Lindeboom, Wietze ;
Onuma, Yoshinobu ;
Serruys, Patrick W. ;
Bartorelli, Antonio L. .
CIRCULATION-CARDIOVASCULAR INTERVENTIONS, 2019, 12 (12)
[3]   Patterns of coronary arterial lesion calcification by a novel, cross-sectional CT angiographic assessment [J].
Cerci, Rodrigo ;
Vavere, Andrea L. ;
Miller, Julie M. ;
Yoneyama, Kihei ;
Rochitte, Carlos E. ;
Dewey, Marc ;
Niinuma, Hiroyuki ;
Clouse, Melvin E. ;
Laham, Roger ;
Bush, David E. ;
Shapiro, Edward P. ;
Lardo, Albert C. ;
Cox, Christopher ;
Brinker, Jeffrey ;
Lima, Joao A. C. ;
Arbab-Zadeh, Armin .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR IMAGING, 2013, 29 (07) :1619-1627
[4]   The diagnostic accuracy of 256-row computed tomographic angiography compared with invasive coronary angiography in patients with suspected coronary artery disease [J].
Chao, Shu-Ping ;
Law, Wai-Yip ;
Kuo, Chu-Jen ;
Hung, Huei-Fong ;
Cheng, Jun-Jack ;
Lo, Huey-Ming ;
Shyu, Kou-Gi .
EUROPEAN HEART JOURNAL, 2010, 31 (15) :1916-1923
[5]   The effect of calcium score on the diagnostic accuracy of coronary computed tomography angiography [J].
Chen, Chien-Cheng ;
Chen, Chun-Chi ;
Hsieh, I-Chang ;
Liu, Yuan-Chang ;
Liu, Chia-Yi ;
Chan, Tiffany ;
Wen, Ming-Shien ;
Wan, Yung-Liang .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR IMAGING, 2011, 27 :37-42
[6]   Diagnostic Accuracy of a Machine-Learning Approach to Coronary Computed Tomographic Angiography-Based Fractional Flow Reserve Result From the MACHINE Consortium [J].
Coenen, Adriaan ;
Kim, Young-Hak ;
Kruk, Mariusz ;
Tesche, Christian ;
De Geer, Jakob ;
Kurata, Akira ;
Lubbers, Marisa L. ;
Daemen, Joost ;
Itu, Lucian ;
Rapaka, Saikiran ;
Sharma, Puneet ;
Schwemmer, Chris ;
Persson, Anders ;
Schoepf, U. Joseph ;
Kepka, Cezary ;
Yang, Dong Hyun ;
Nieman, Koen .
CIRCULATION-CARDIOVASCULAR IMAGING, 2018, 11 (06)
[7]   Fractional Flow Reserve Derived From Computed Tomographic Angiography in Patients With Multivessel CAD [J].
Collet, Carlos ;
Miyazaki, Yosuke ;
Ryan, Nicola ;
Asano, Taku ;
Tenekecioglu, Erhan ;
Sonck, Jeroen ;
Andreini, Daniele ;
Sabate, Manel ;
Brugaletta, Salvatore ;
Stables, Rodney H. ;
Bartorelli, Antonio ;
de Winter, Robbert J. ;
Katagiri, Yuki ;
Chichareon, Ply ;
De Maria, Giovanni Luigi ;
Suwannasom, Pannipa ;
Cavalcante, Rafael ;
Jonker, Hans ;
Morel, Marie-angele ;
Cosyns, Bernard ;
Kappetein, Arie P. ;
Taggart, David T. ;
Farooq, Vasim ;
Escaned, Javier ;
Banning, Adrian ;
Onuma, Yoshinobu ;
Serruys, Patrick W. .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY, 2018, 71 (24) :2756-2769
[8]   COMPARING THE AREAS UNDER 2 OR MORE CORRELATED RECEIVER OPERATING CHARACTERISTIC CURVES - A NONPARAMETRIC APPROACH [J].
DELONG, ER ;
DELONG, DM ;
CLARKEPEARSON, DI .
BIOMETRICS, 1988, 44 (03) :837-845
[9]   Machine-Learning CT-FFR and Extensive Coronary Calcium Overcoming the Achilles Heel of Coronary Computed Tomography Angiography [J].
Dey, Damini ;
Lin, Andrew .
JACC-CARDIOVASCULAR IMAGING, 2020, 13 (03) :771-773
[10]   Coronary CT angiography-derived plaque quantification with artificial intelligence CT fractional flow reserve for the identification of lesion-specific ischemia [J].
Doeberitz, Philipp L. von Knebel ;
De Cecco, Carlo N. ;
Schoepf, U. Joseph ;
Duguay, Taylor M. ;
Albrecht, Moritz H. ;
van Assen, Marly ;
Bauer, Maximilian J. ;
Savage, Rock H. ;
Pannell, J. Trent ;
De Santis, Domenico ;
Johnson, Addison A. ;
Varga-Szemes, Akos ;
Bayer, Richard R. ;
Schoenberg, Stefan O. ;
Nance, John W. ;
Tesche, Christian .
EUROPEAN RADIOLOGY, 2019, 29 (05) :2378-2387