Electroconvulsive therapy, the placebo effect and informed consent

被引:25
作者
Blease, Charlotte Rosalind [1 ]
机构
[1] Queens Univ Belfast, Sch Polit Int Studies & Philosophy, Belfast BT7 1PA, Antrim, North Ireland
关键词
DEPRESSION; MEMORY; PHARMACOTHERAPY; PREVENTION; EFFICACY; ECT;
D O I
10.1136/medethics-2012-100955
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
Major depressive disorder is not only the most widespread mental disorder in the world, it is a disorder on the rise. In cases of particularly severe forms of depression, when all other treatment options have failed, the use of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is a recommended treatment option for patients. ECT has been in use in psychiatric practice for over 70 years and is now undergoing something of a restricted renaissance following a sharp decline in its use in the 1970s. Despite its success in treating severe depression there is continued debate as to the effectiveness of ECT: in some studies, it is argued that ECT is marginally more effective than sham ECT. In addition, there is still no clear explanation of how ECT works; among the range of hypotheses proposed it is claimed that ECT may work by harnessing placebo effects. In light of the uncertainties over the mechanism of action of ECT and given the risk of serious side effects that ECT may produce, I contend that the process of informed consent must include comprehensive accounts of these uncertainties. I examine the possible consequences of providing adequate information to potential ECT patients, including the consideration that ECT may still prove to be effective even if physicians are open about the possibility of it working as a placebo. I conclude that if we value patient autonomy as well as the professional reputation of medical practitioners, a fuller description of ECT must be provided to patients and their carers.
引用
收藏
页码:166 / 170
页数:5
相关论文
共 41 条
[1]  
AMA, 2011, INF CONS
[2]  
AMA, 2006, OP 8 08 INF CONS
[3]  
American Medical Association (AMA), 2007, OP 8 083 PLAC US CLI
[4]  
[Anonymous], 2008, DECL HELS
[5]  
[Anonymous], 2009, DEPR TREATM MAN DEPR
[6]  
[Anonymous], 1999, Mental Health: A Report of the Surgeon General
[7]  
1999 ASI 4048-47
[8]  
APA, 2002, PRACT EL THER
[9]  
Blease C, 2010, JME, V37, P13
[10]   Deception as treatment: the case of depression [J].
Blease, Charlotte .
JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ETHICS, 2011, 37 (01) :13-16