Philemon and Baucis syndrome: Three additional cases of double deaths of married couples

被引:6
作者
Delannoy, Y. [1 ]
Tournel, G. [1 ]
Dedouit, F. [2 ]
Cornez, R. [1 ]
Telmon, N. [2 ]
Hedouin, V. [1 ]
Rouge, D. [2 ]
Gosset, D. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Lille Nord France, CHRU Lille, Inst Med Legale, Fac Med, F-59045 Lille, France
[2] CHU Toulouse Rangueil, Fac Med, Lab Med Legale, F-31059 Toulouse, France
关键词
Philemon and Baucis syndrome; Negative autopsy; Stress; Sudden cardiac death; Simultaneous deaths; FORENSIC APPROACH; STRESS;
D O I
10.1016/j.forsciint.2013.01.021
中图分类号
DF [法律]; D9 [法律]; R [医药、卫生];
学科分类号
0301 ; 10 ;
摘要
The simultaneous death of two people is immediately considered as a suspect. However, this feeling is reinforced when the individuals are spouses. In these situations, criminal and forensic investigations are required to establish whether or not the deaths were homicidal in nature. Despite many descriptions of simultaneous deaths being present in the literature, the simultaneous death of two spouses from natural causes is poorly described with Ciesiolka et al., Department of Legal Medicine in Giessen (Germany), being the only ones to have reviewed two case reports involving these circumstances. The scarcity of this type of information in the literature renders the task of claiming natural simultaneous death as the final outcome of an investigation difficult. We would like to report three additional cases with the aim of better describing this type of event. In all three cases, the bodies were those of a married couple in their 80s. The bodies were discovered in the same room. In each case, the death of one of the spouses could be attributed to natural cause; however the death of the other spouse could not be determined with certainty, and shared several similarities in all cases: simultaneity in death; a pre existing cardiovascular disease/disorder; a certain degree of fragility and dependence on the other spouse whose death could lead to acute psychological stress. Intense psychological disorder could trigger acute coronary or rhythmic disorders. The mechanisms by which brain activity influences cardiac electrophysiology are now known to take place via the autonomic nervous system mediation. This brain activity could provide an explanation for the death of the individuals with pre-existing heart conditions, who underwent significant stress upon occurrence of the death of their partners. The death of these individuals, which took place at the same place and time as their deceased spouses, can be attributed to natural causes: the Philemon and Baucis syndrome. (C) 2013 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:E32 / E36
页数:5
相关论文
共 21 条
[1]   PARADOXICAL UNDRESSING IN FATAL HYPOTHERMIA (HOMO TIROLENSIS) [J].
AMBACH, E .
LANCET, 1993, 341 (8855) :1285-1285
[2]   HUMAN STRESS CARDIOMYOPATHY - MYOCARDIAL LESIONS IN VICTIMS OF HOMICIDAL ASSAULTS WITHOUT INTERNAL INJURIES [J].
CEBELIN, MS ;
HIRSCH, CS .
HUMAN PATHOLOGY, 1980, 11 (02) :123-132
[3]   Philemon and Baucis Death? Two cases of double deaths of married couples [J].
Ciesiolka, Sabrina ;
Risse, Manfred ;
Busch, Bernd ;
Verhoff, Marcel A. .
FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL, 2008, 176 (2-3) :E7-E10
[4]  
COUMEL P, 1978, ARCH MAL COEUR VAISS, V71, P645
[5]  
DAVIS JH, 1978, J FORENSIC SCI, V23, P384
[6]  
De Giorgio F., 2009, LEGAL MED, V11, P531
[7]   Forensic approach of fatal dog attacks: a case report and literature review [J].
De Munnynck, K ;
Van de Voorde, W .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LEGAL MEDICINE, 2002, 116 (05) :295-300
[8]   POSTEXERCISE PERIL - PLASMA-CATECHOLAMINES AND EXERCISE [J].
DIMSDALE, JE ;
HARTLEY, LH ;
GUINEY, T ;
RUSKIN, JN ;
GREENBLATT, D .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 1984, 251 (05) :630-632
[9]  
GERSHMAN KA, 1994, PEDIATRICS, V93, P913
[10]   PHILEMON AND BAUCIS IN OVID 'METAMORPHOSES' [J].
GRIFFIN, AHF .
GREECE & ROME, 1991, 38 (01) :62-74