Why Play the Notes? Indirect Aesthetic Normativity in Performance

被引:9
作者
Rohrbaugh, Guy [1 ]
机构
[1] Auburn Univ, Auburn, AL 36849 USA
关键词
music; performance; authenticity; reasons; value; practice; ONTOLOGY;
D O I
10.1080/00048402.2019.1600563
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
While all agree that score compliance in performance is valuable, the source of this value is unclear. Questions about what authenticity requires crowd out questions about our reasons to be compliant in the first place, perhaps because they seem trivial or uninteresting. I argue that such reasons cannot be understood as ordinary aesthetic, instrumental, epistemic, or moral reasons. Instead, we treat considerations of score compliance as having a kind of final value, one which requires further explanation. Taking as a model the Humean account of fidelity as an artificial virtue, I sketch a practice-theoretic account of the nature and source of such reasons, one on which we can say that they are, after all, aesthetic, but only indirectly so.
引用
收藏
页码:78 / 91
页数:14
相关论文
共 28 条
[1]   MOTIVE UTILITARIANISM [J].
ADAMS, RM .
JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 1976, 73 (14) :467-481
[2]  
Amira John., 1992, The Music of Santeria: Traditional Rhythms of the Bata Drums
[3]  
[Anonymous], MORAL PHILOS
[4]  
Benjamin W., 1968, Illuminations, P219
[5]   ENIGMATIC VARIATIONS [J].
Davies, David .
MONIST, 2012, 95 (04) :643-662
[6]   AUTHENTICITY IN MUSICAL PERFORMANCE [J].
DAVIES, S .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF AESTHETICS, 1987, 27 (01) :39-50
[7]  
Davies Stephen., 2001, MUSICAL WORKS PERFOR
[8]   Performing Works of Music Authentically [J].
Dodd, Julian .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 2015, 23 (03) :485-508
[9]   Performing compositions + Classical music, aesthetics of practice [J].
Edidin, A .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF AESTHETICS, 1997, 37 (04) :323-335
[10]  
Edidin Aron., 1991, MIDWEST STUD PHILOS, V16, P394