Low sensitivity of the ki-ras polymerase chain reaction for diagnosing pancreatic cancer from pancreatic juice and bile:: A multicenter prospective trial

Purpose : Early detection of pancreatic cancer using molecular markers may improve outcome. Mutations of the ki-ras oncogene are detected in 70% to 90% of pancreatic adenocarcinomas. A prospective, partially blinded, multicenter diagnostic trial was performed to test the sensitivity and specificity of the ki-ras polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of pancreatic juice and bile specimens. Patients and Methods: Specimens of pancreatic juice and bile were collected from 532 consecutive patients. Mutations in codon 12 of the ki-ras gene were identified by two independent enrichment PCRs and confirmed by direct sequencing. Results: One hundred seventy-four of 532 patients were excluded from the final analysis (reasons: no amplifiable DNA, no specimen or only duodenal juice sent, lost to follow-up). Sixty-three of 358 patients had ductal pancreatic cancer. In 24 (38.1%) of 63 patients, a mutated ki-ras gene was identified in pancreatic juice and/or bile. Ki-ras mutations were found in four (8%) of 50 cases of chronic pancreatitis, in 10 (18.7%) of 53 cases of other malignancies of the pancreaticobiliary tree, and in 14 (7.3%) of 192 cases of benign diseases or normal findings. Sensitivity and specificity of the ki-ras PCR analysis for the detection of pancreatic cancer was 38.1% and 90.5%, respectively. Conclusion: In this prospective trial performed in non-selected patients, mutations of the ki-ras gene were detected in 38.1% of cases with pancreatic cancer. This test in its present form is not appropriate to confirm or screen for pancreatic cancer. More sensitive and/or quantitative PCR tests may improve the molecular diagnosis of pancreatic cancer. (C) 2002 by American Society of Clinical Oncology.