Comment on 'On the Clausius equality and inequality'

被引:2
作者
Bizarro, Joao P. S. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Tecn Lisboa, EURATOM Assoc, IST, Inst Plasmas & Fusao Nucl,Inst Super Tecn, P-1049001 Lisbon, Portugal
关键词
THERMODYNAMICS; WORK; DEFINITIONS; HEAT;
D O I
10.1088/0143-0807/34/1/L11
中图分类号
G40 [教育学];
学科分类号
040101 ; 120403 ;
摘要
Errors and/or inconsistencies in recent papers on the Clausius inequality and its rectification (2011 Eur. J. Phys. 32 279; 2011 Eur. J. Phys. 32 845) are pointed out that have to do with the fact that the dissipative work therein is not split into its two components: a part coming from friction and ending up delivered as heat to the system and/or surroundings plus a part corresponding to the extra work that would not be wasted if the transformation were reversible. Also criticized, as potential sources of confusion, are the attempts in that paper to clarify so-called subtleties and misunderstandings related to the definition of heat and the computation of the entropy change of a system.
引用
收藏
页码:L11 / L16
页数:6
相关论文
共 15 条
[1]   On the Clausius equality and inequality (vol 32, pg 279, 2010) [J].
Anacleto, Joaquim .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS, 2011, 32 (03) :845-845
[2]   On the Clausius equality and inequality [J].
Anacleto, Joaquim .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS, 2011, 32 (02) :279-286
[3]   Dissipative work in thermodynamics [J].
Anacleto, Joaquim ;
Pereira, Mario G. ;
Ferreira, J. M. .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS, 2011, 32 (01) :37-47
[4]   Average entropy dissipation in irreversible mesoscopic processes [J].
Ben-Amotz, D ;
Honig, JM .
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 2006, 96 (02)
[5]   Rectification of thermodynamic inequalities [J].
Ben-Amotz, D ;
Honig, JM .
JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS, 2003, 118 (13) :5932-5936
[6]   The rectified second law of thermodynamics [J].
Ben-Amotz, Dor ;
Honig, J. M. .
JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY B, 2006, 110 (40) :19966-19972
[7]   Thermodynamics with friction. I. The Clausius inequality revisited (vol 108, 054907, 2010) [J].
Bizarro, Joao P. S. .
JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSICS, 2011, 109 (01)
[8]   Thermodynamics with friction. I. The Clausius inequality revisited [J].
Bizarro, Joao P. S. .
JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSICS, 2010, 108 (05)
[9]   Entropy production in irreversible processes with friction [J].
Bizarro, Joao P. S. .
PHYSICAL REVIEW E, 2008, 78 (02)
[10]   Cementing the foundations of thermodynamics: Comparison of system-based and surroundings-based definitions of work and heat [J].
Gislason, EA ;
Craig, NC .
JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL THERMODYNAMICS, 2005, 37 (09) :954-966