Clinical Outcomes of Total Ankle Arthroplasty Versus Ankle Arthrodesis for the Treatment of End-Stage Ankle Arthritis in the Last Decade: a Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

被引:60
作者
Shih, Chia-Lung [1 ]
Chen, Shu-Jung [1 ]
Huang, Peng-Ju [2 ]
机构
[1] Kaohsiung Med Univ Hosp, Dept Orthoped, Kaohsiung, Taiwan
[2] Kaohsiung Med Univ, Coll Med, Kaohsiung, Taiwan
关键词
ankle arthrodesis; end-stage ankle arthritis; third-generation implant; total ankle arthroplasty; FOLLOW-UP; REPLACEMENT; COMPLICATIONS; INTERMEDIATE; GAIT;
D O I
10.1053/j.jfas.2019.10.008
中图分类号
R826.8 [整形外科学]; R782.2 [口腔颌面部整形外科学]; R726.2 [小儿整形外科学]; R62 [整形外科学(修复外科学)];
学科分类号
摘要
Ankle arthrodesis (AA) and total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) are the 2 primary surgical treatments for patients with end-stage ankle arthritis. The comparative outcomes between AA and TAA using modern techniques remain unclear. A systematic search to identify all relevant articles comparing AA with TAA was conducted through 3 online databases. The clinical outcomes were extracted for meta-analysis, including AOFAS (American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society) score, VAS (visual analog scale), AOS (Ankle Osteoarthritis Scale), gait analysis, ROM (range of motion), satisfaction, complication, and reoperation. Our meta-analysis shows no heterogeneity in any subgroup analyses. There were no significant differences in AOFAS total, pain, and alignment scores between the AA and TAA groups. The TAA group had significant improvement in AOFAS function score compared with the AA group. There was no significant difference in VAS and AOS total scores between the 2 groups. No significant differences in gait analysis were observed between the 2 groups. The TAA group had significant improvement in both ROM and change in ROM compared with the AA group. There was no significant difference in satisfaction rate between the 2 groups. The TAA group had significantly higher complication and reoperation rates compared with the AA group. Our meta-analysis provides updated evidence on clinical outcomes comparing AA with TAA using third-generation implants. The TAA group had better improvement in AOFAS function and ROM than the AA group. No significant differences in pain relief, gait analysis, or patient satisfaction were observed between the 2 groups. (C) 2019 by the American College of Foot and Ankle Surgeons. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:1032 / 1039
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   The efficacy and safety of tranexamic acid utilization in total ankle arthroplasty: a systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
Edelstein, Alexander ;
McDonald, John ;
Lachance, Andrew D. ;
Giro, Margaret Elizabeth ;
Lee, Wonyong .
ARCHIVES OF ORTHOPAEDIC AND TRAUMA SURGERY, 2024, 144 (02) :641-649
[42]   Patient Expectation and Satisfaction as Measures of Operative Outcome in End-Stage Ankle Arthritis: A Prospective Cohort Study of Total Ankle Replacement Versus Ankle Fusion [J].
Younger, Alastair S. E. ;
Wing, Kevin J. ;
Glazebrook, Mark ;
Daniels, Timothy R. ;
Dryden, Peter J. ;
Lalonde, Karl-Andre ;
Wong, Hubert ;
Qian, Hong ;
Penner, Murray .
FOOT & ANKLE INTERNATIONAL, 2015, 36 (02) :123-134
[43]   Effectiveness of Ilizarov Ankle Arthrodesis in the Treatment of End-Stage Varus Ankle Osteoarthritis: A Retrospective Study [J].
Li, Bohua ;
Wang, Shanxi ;
Li, Qin ;
Zhang, Zhengdong ;
Li, Jun ;
Yang, Hai ;
Liu, Lei .
ORTHOPAEDIC SURGERY, 2022, 14 (05) :937-945
[44]   Outcomes after total ankle arthroplasty with an average follow-up of 10 years: A systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
Bagheri, Kian ;
Anastasio, Albert T. ;
Poehlein, Emily ;
Green, Cynthia L. ;
Aitchison, Alexandra H. ;
Cantor, Nicole ;
Hendren, Stephanie ;
Adams, Samuel B. .
FOOT AND ANKLE SURGERY, 2024, 30 (01) :64-73
[45]   A comparative study of modern total ankle replacement and ankle arthrodesis for ankle osteoarthritis at different follow-up times: a systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
Shuai Liu ;
Yuxin Wang ;
Mengqi Zhang ;
Pengcheng Wei ;
Yujing Li ;
Tongyu Wang ;
Qingyang Meng .
International Orthopaedics, 2023, 47 :1493-1510
[46]   The role of total ankle replacement in patients with haemophilia and end-stage ankle arthropathy: A review [J].
Sackstein, Paul ;
Cooper, Paul ;
Kessler, Craig .
HAEMOPHILIA, 2021, 27 (02) :184-191
[47]   A systematic review of outcomes of total ankle arthroplasty with INBONE II [J].
Ashy, Cody C. ;
Reid, Jared J. ;
Morningstar, Joshua L. ;
Brennan, Emily ;
Scott, Daniel J. ;
Gross, Christopher E. .
FOOT AND ANKLE SURGERY, 2025, 31 (03) :190-198
[48]   Return to Sports and Activity After Total Ankle Arthroplasty and Arthrodesis: A Systematic Review [J].
Johns, William L. ;
Sowers, Christopher B. ;
Walley, Kempland C. ;
Ross, Daniel ;
Thordarson, David B. ;
Jackson, Ben ;
Gonzalez, Tyler .
FOOT & ANKLE INTERNATIONAL, 2020, 41 (08) :916-929
[49]   The mid-term outcome of total ankle arthroplasty and ankle fusion in rheumatoid arthritis: a systematic review [J].
van Heiningen, Jacqueline ;
Vlieland, Thea P. M. Vliet ;
van der Heide, Huub J. L. .
BMC MUSCULOSKELETAL DISORDERS, 2013, 14
[50]   Total Ankle Arthroplasty Survivorship: A Meta-analysis [J].
McKenna, Bryon J. ;
Cook, Jeremy ;
Cook, Emily A. ;
Crafton, Jordan ;
Knabel, Matthew ;
Swenson, Eric ;
Miner, Samantha ;
Manning, Elena ;
Basile, Philip .
JOURNAL OF FOOT & ANKLE SURGERY, 2020, 59 (05) :1040-1048