Exploring Attitudes toward Animal Welfare through the Lens of Subjectivity-An Application of Q-Methodology

被引:5
|
作者
Vecchio, Yari [1 ]
Pauselli, Gregorio [1 ]
Adinolfi, Felice [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Bologna, Dept Vet Med Sci, I-40064 Ozzano Dellemilia, BO, Italy
来源
ANIMALS | 2020年 / 10卷 / 08期
关键词
animal welfare; opinions; Q-methodology; policymaking; discourses; PUBLIC-ATTITUDES; DEMOCRACY; PERSPECTIVES; GOVERNANCE; DISCOURSES; BEHAVIORS; INSIGHTS; SCIENCE; CITIZEN; VIEWS;
D O I
10.3390/ani10081364
中图分类号
S8 [畜牧、 动物医学、狩猎、蚕、蜂];
学科分类号
0905 ;
摘要
Simple Summary In this paper, we offer a methodological solution to the policymaker to improve the structure of the surveys used for public consultations. Over the years, we noticed the importance of opinions in legislative processes, particularly in animal welfare. The issue, to which European citizens have historically been sensitive, has been the target of multiple consultations aimed at considering perceptions about farming conditions. However, standard surveys suffer from bias and design errors. To overcome these problems, we propose the use of Q-methodology to understand the opinions of veterinary students. The results contribute to the improvement of traditional surveys used to understand what people think about animal welfare and could be useful in providing information to the policy making process. Opinions increasingly influence legislative processes. The case of animal welfare (AW) standards is a clear example of the role played by opinions in political decisions. The issue, to which European citizens have historically been sensitive, has been the subject of numerous consultations and investigations, aimed at considering citizens' opinions regarding breeding conditions. However, these tools and in particular standard surveys, suffer from response biases such as the prejudices involved in the design of questions and the interpretation of the results. To mitigate these problems, we used the Q-methodology, which is an inductive but systematic methodology focused on patterns that explain the ideas of individuals. The purposive sample consisted of 36 veterinary students who were acquiring scientific knowledge about AW. The results, in addition to providing policymakers with food for thought for the further development of AW standards, contribute to testing the use of alternative methodologies to collect citizens' views. This mapping of viewpoints helps to build a more effective form of AW policy making.
引用
收藏
页码:1 / 14
页数:14
相关论文
共 16 条
  • [1] Attitudes of elderly Korean patients toward death and dying: an application of Q-methodology
    Yeun, E
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NURSING STUDIES, 2005, 42 (08) : 871 - 880
  • [3] Subjectivity of Nursing College Students' Awareness of Gender Equality: An Application of Q-methodology
    Yeun, Eun Ja
    Kwon, Hye Jin
    Kim, Hyun Jeong
    JOURNAL OF KOREAN ACADEMY OF NURSING, 2012, 42 (03) : 342 - 350
  • [4] Categorizing College Students by Academic Attitudes: An Application of Q-Methodology Approach
    Liu, Liguang
    2014 INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ADVANCED EDUCATION AND MANAGEMENT (ICAEM), 2014, : 237 - 243
  • [5] BRAZILIAN ATTITUDES TOWARD AGRARIAN-REFORM - A Q-METHODOLOGY OPINION STUDY OF A CONFLICTUAL ISSUE
    PERITORE, NP
    PERITORE, AKG
    JOURNAL OF DEVELOPING AREAS, 1990, 24 (03): : 377 - 405
  • [6] Care for a break? An investigation of informal caregivers' attitudes toward respite care using Q-methodology
    van Exel, Job
    de Graaf, Gjalt
    Brouwer, Werner
    HEALTH POLICY, 2007, 83 (2-3) : 332 - 342
  • [7] Anatomy beyond the pandemic: A Q-methodology study exploring student perceptions toward a hybrid curriculum
    Metla, Sai Gayathri
    Akhtar-Danesh, Noori
    Saini, Jessica
    Bayer, Ilana
    Mezil, Yasmeen
    Brewer-Deluce, Danielle
    Wainman, Bruce C.
    ANATOMICAL SCIENCES EDUCATION, 2024, 17 (04) : 831 - 843
  • [8] Exploring perspectives of environmental best management practices in Thai agriculture: an application of Q-methodology
    Bumbudsanpharoke, Wimolpat
    Moran, Dominic
    Hall, Clare
    ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION, 2009, 36 (03) : 225 - 234
  • [9] Exploring the impact of traumatic experiences on undergraduate social work students' professional attitudes: using Q-methodology
    Lee, HeeSoon
    Adams, Peggy
    Lim, Sooyeon
    Molnar, Matt
    SOCIAL WORK EDUCATION, 2023, 42 (08) : 1248 - 1266
  • [10] Attitudes toward stress and coping among primary caregivers of patients undergoing hemodialysis: A Q-methodology study
    Yeun, Eun Ja
    Bang, Ho Yoon
    Kim, Eun Jung
    Jeon, Misoon
    Jang, Eun Sil
    Ham, Eunmi
    HEMODIALYSIS INTERNATIONAL, 2016, 20 (03) : 453 - 462