Relative, but not absolute, thinning responses decline with increasing thinning age in a Eucalyptus nitens plantation

Growth rates of trees and stand structure change as stands age, and therefore absolute and relative thinning responses may also vary with thinning age. The study examined whether thinning age influenced the relative and absolute thinning responses in Eucalyptus nitens plantations near Carrajung, Victoria, Australia, and whether this effect was influenced by nitrogen (N) fertiliser application. Two levels of thinning and fertiliser application were applied in a factorial design replicated three times in a randomised block layout in each of two trials established in September 2006 in adjacent plantations aged 3.2 y and 13.2 y respectively and from the same seed source. Treatments included: unthinned or thinned non-commercially from below to 300 trees ha(-1); fertiliser treatments were nil or 300 kg ha(-1) N as urea in the younger trial and nil or mixed fertiliser supplying 256 kg ha(-1) N, 80 kg ha(-1) P and 100 kg ha(-1) K in the older trial. Five years after thinning, basal areas of the largest 200 sawlog crop trees ha(-1) (SCTs) were about 4.1 m(2) ha(-1) greater in thinned than in unthinned stands, regardless of thinning age, and volumes of SCTs were 30.1 m(3) ha(-1) greater in thinned stands. As a result of the greater standing basal area and volumes in the older trial, relative thinning responses of SCTs were greater in the younger trial, such that thinning increased the basal area of the SCT200 by about 42% (and volume by 32%) in the younger trial, but by only 21% (and volume by 17%) in the older trial. Fertiliser application also increased absolute thinning responses. Smaller relative thinning responses in the older stand were associated with age-related changes in stand structure of unthinned stands, including increasing skewness and decreasing kurtosis of diameter distributions as stands aged. The absence of a thinning-age effect on absolute responses suggests that there is some flexibility in the thinning age in E. nitens plantations. However, it is important to note that while the absolute thinning response may be slow to decline, the size of the SCTs will be smaller after later-age thinning owing to the extended period of competition they experience prior to thinning.