The hardness of the hydroxyapatite-titania bilayer coatings by microindentation and nanoindentation testing

The aim of this paper is to investigate the effect of the addition of titania (TiO2) innerlayer on the morphological and mechanical properties of hydroxyapatite (HAP) bioceramic coatings deposited on 316L stainless steel (316L SS) by sol-gel method in order to improve the properties of hydroxyapatite and expand its clinical application. The addition of TiO2 as sublayer of a hydroxyapatite coating results in changes in surface morphology as well as an increase of the microhardness. The deposition of the inner-layer provides the formation of new types of hydroxyapatite coatings at the same condition of annealing. This represents an advantage for the various applications of the hydroxyapatite bioceramic in the medical field. Classical hardness measurements conducted on the coated systems under the same indentation load (10g) indicated that the microhardness of the HAP coating is improved by the addition of TiO2 inner-layer on the 316L stainless steel substrate. The hardness values obtained from both classical tests in microindentation and the continuous stiffness measurement mode in nanoindentation are slightly different. This is because nanoindentation is more sensitive to the surface roughness and the influence of defects that could be present into the material. Moreover, nanoindentation is the most useful method to separate the contribution of each layer in the bilayer coatings. In this study, the hardness is comparable with those reported previously for pure HAP ceramics (1.05.5 GPa) which are close to the properties of natural teeth.