Irreproducibility in hydrogen storage material research

被引:114
作者
Broom, D. P. [1 ]
Hirscher, M. [2 ]
机构
[1] Hiden Isochema Ltd, 422 Europa Blvd, Warrington WA5 7TS, Cheshire, England
[2] Max Planck Inst Intelligent Syst, Heisenbergstr 3, D-70569 Stuttgart, Germany
关键词
THERMAL-DESORPTION SPECTROSCOPY; METAL-ORGANIC FRAMEWORKS; DOPED CARBON NANOTUBES; SURFACE-AREA; SORPTION MEASUREMENTS; SCIENTIFIC LITERATURE; ADSORPTION PROPERTIES; SPILLOVER; REPLICATION; TEMPERATURE;
D O I
10.1039/c6ee01435f
中图分类号
O6 [化学];
学科分类号
0703 ;
摘要
The storage of hydrogen in materials has received a significant amount of attention in recent years because this approach is widely thought to be one of the most promising solutions to the problem of storing hydrogen for use as an alternative energy carrier in a safe, compact and affordable form. However, there have been a number of high profile cases in which erroneous or irreproducible data have been published. Meanwhile, the irreproducibility of research results in a wide range of disciplines has been the subject of an increasing amount of attention due to problems with some of the data in the literature. In this Perspective, we provide a summary of the problems that have affected hydrogen storage material research. We also discuss the reasons behind them and possible ways of reducing the likelihood of further problems occurring in the future.
引用
收藏
页码:3368 / 3380
页数:13
相关论文
共 134 条
[1]   Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science [J].
Aarts, Alexander A. ;
Anderson, Joanna E. ;
Anderson, Christopher J. ;
Attridge, Peter R. ;
Attwood, Angela ;
Axt, Jordan ;
Babel, Molly ;
Bahnik, Stepan ;
Baranski, Erica ;
Barnett-Cowan, Michael ;
Bartmess, Elizabeth ;
Beer, Jennifer ;
Bell, Raoul ;
Bentley, Heather ;
Beyan, Leah ;
Binion, Grace ;
Borsboom, Denny ;
Bosch, Annick ;
Bosco, Frank A. ;
Bowman, Sara D. ;
Brandt, Mark J. ;
Braswell, Erin ;
Brohmer, Hilmar ;
Brown, Benjamin T. ;
Brown, Kristina ;
Bruening, Jovita ;
Calhoun-Sauls, Ann ;
Callahan, Shannon P. ;
Chagnon, Elizabeth ;
Chandler, Jesse ;
Chartier, Christopher R. ;
Cheung, Felix ;
Christopherson, Cody D. ;
Cillessen, Linda ;
Clay, Russ ;
Cleary, Hayley ;
Cloud, Mark D. ;
Cohn, Michael ;
Cohoon, Johanna ;
Columbus, Simon ;
Cordes, Andreas ;
Costantini, Giulio ;
Alvarez, Leslie D. Cramblet ;
Cremata, Ed ;
Crusius, Jan ;
DeCoster, Jamie ;
DeGaetano, Michelle A. ;
Della Penna, Nicolas ;
den Bezemer, Bobby ;
Deserno, Marie K. .
SCIENCE, 2015, 349 (6251)
[2]   Hydrogen desorption and adsorption measurements on graphite nanofibers [J].
Ahn, CC ;
Ye, Y ;
Ratnakumar, BV ;
Witham, C ;
Bowman, RC ;
Fultz, B .
APPLIED PHYSICS LETTERS, 1998, 73 (23) :3378-3380
[3]   Journals unite for reproducibility [J].
不详 .
NATURE, 2014, 515 (7525) :7-7
[4]   Further confirmation needed [J].
不详 .
NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY, 2012, 30 (09) :806-806
[5]  
[Anonymous], NATURE
[6]  
[Anonymous], 2003, Mater. Today, DOI [10.1016/S1369-7021(03)00922-2, DOI 10.1016/S1369-7021(03)00922-2]
[7]  
[Anonymous], 2013, NATURE, DOI DOI 10.1038/496398a
[8]   Hydrogen adsorption on a single-walled carbon nanotube material:: a comparative study of three different adsorption techniques [J].
Ansón, A ;
Benham, M ;
Jagiello, J ;
Callejas, MA ;
Benito, AM ;
Maser, WK ;
Züttel, A ;
Sudan, P ;
Martínez, MT .
NANOTECHNOLOGY, 2004, 15 (11) :1503-1508
[9]   Nanoporous polypyrrole: preparation and hydrogen storage properties [J].
Attia, Nour F. ;
Lee, Sang M. ;
Kim, Hae J. ;
Geckeler, Kurt E. .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENERGY RESEARCH, 2014, 38 (04) :466-476
[10]   Catalytic mechanism of transition-metal compounds on Mg hydrogen sorption reaction [J].
Barkhordarian, Gagik ;
Klassen, Thomas ;
Bormann, Rudiger .
JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY B, 2006, 110 (22) :11020-11024