Propensity Score-Matched Analysis Comparing Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery with Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy for Large Stones in Patients with a Solitary Kidney

被引:32
作者
Shi, Xiaolei [1 ]
Peng, Yonghan [1 ]
Li, Xiao [2 ]
Wang, Qi [1 ]
Li, Ling [1 ]
Liu, Min [1 ]
Gao, Xiaofeng [1 ]
Sun, Yinghao [1 ]
机构
[1] Second Mil Med Univ, Shanghai Changhai Hosp, Dept Urol, 168 Changhai Rd, Shanghai 200433, Peoples R China
[2] Second Mil Med Univ, Shanghai Changhai Hosp, Dept Radiol, Shanghai, Peoples R China
基金
中国国家自然科学基金;
关键词
solitary kidney; renal calculi; percutaneous nephrolithotomy; retrograde intrarenal surgery; CLINICAL-RESEARCH OFFICE; HOLMIUM LASER; RENAL STONES; CM; COMPLICATIONS; OUTCOMES; LITHOTRIPSY; MANAGEMENT; TRACT; DILATION;
D O I
10.1089/end.2017.0482
中图分类号
R5 [内科学]; R69 [泌尿科学(泌尿生殖系疾病)];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Purpose: To evaluate the clinical efficacy, safety, and cost of retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS) and percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) in the treatment for large renal stones in patients with a solitary kidney. Patients and Methods: In this study, 117 patients with a solitary kidney who had undergone PCNL or RIRS for renal stones larger than 2 cm between January 2010 and December 2016 were retrospectively evaluated. The patients' demographic data, clinical characteristics, and perioperative outcomes were collected through a review of their medical records. Forty-three patients treated with PCNL were compared to 43 patients treated with RIRS by propensity score-matched analysis. The stone-free rate, retreatment rate, complication rate, and efficacy quotient (EQ) were assessed in both groups. Results: Initial stone-free rate of the PCNL group after a single procedure was significantly higher compared with the RIRS group (74.42% vs 34.88%, p < 0.001), whereas there was no significant difference in the final stone-free rate after repeated procedures (90.70% vs 88.37%, p = 0.713). PCNL had a significantly lower retreatment rate than RIRS (16.28% vs 63.79%, p < 0.001), and the PCNL group underwent fewer procedures than the RIRS group (p < 0.001). Thus, PCNL group had a higher EQ (78.00% vs 53.52%). Although cost per procedure of PCNL was significantly higher compared with RIRS (p < 0.001), the total costs were comparable. Complication rate of RIRS was lower compared with PCNL with no statistical significance (p = 0.193), and acute kidney injury rates were also comparable (PCNL vs RIRS: 13.95% vs 6.98%, p = 0.533). Conclusions: With fewer repeated surgical procedures, higher EQ, and comparable total costs, PCNL is recommended as the first choice for the treatment of large renal calculi in patients with a solitary kidney. As for specific indications such as anticoagulant drugs, RIRS is a safer choice with fewer complications and acceptable final stone-free rate.
引用
收藏
页码:198 / 204
页数:7
相关论文
共 34 条
[1]   Comparison of percutaneous nephrolithotomy and retrograde flexible nephrolithotripsy for the management of 2-4 cm stones: a matched-pair analysis [J].
Akman, Tolga ;
Binbay, Murat ;
Ozgor, Faruk ;
Ugurlu, Mesut ;
Tekinarslan, Erdem ;
Kezer, Cem ;
Aslan, Rahmi ;
Muslumanoglu, Ahmet Yaser .
BJU INTERNATIONAL, 2012, 109 (09) :1384-1389
[2]   Outcomes of Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy in Patients With Solitary Kidneys: A Single-center Experience [J].
Akman, Tolga ;
Binbay, Murat ;
Tekinarslan, Erdem ;
Ozkuvanci, Unsal ;
Kezer, Cem ;
Erbin, Akif ;
Berberoglu, Yalcin ;
Yaser-Muslumanoglu, Ahmet .
UROLOGY, 2011, 78 (02) :272-276
[3]   Flexible ureteroscopy: Technological advancements, current indications and outcomes in the treatment of urolithiasis [J].
Alenezi, Husain ;
Denstedt, John D. .
ASIAN JOURNAL OF UROLOGY, 2015, 2 (03) :133-141
[4]   Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery for the Treatment of Renal Stones in Patients With a Solitary Kidney [J].
Atis, Gokhan ;
Gurbuz, Cenk ;
Arikan, Ozgur ;
Kilic, Mert ;
Pelit, Sabri ;
Canakci, Cengiz ;
Gungor, Samet ;
Caskurlu, Turhan .
UROLOGY, 2013, 82 (02) :290-294
[5]   Percutaneous nephrolithotomy versus retrograde intrarenal surgery for the treatment of kidney stones up to 2 cm in patients with solitary kidney: a single centre experience [J].
Bai, Yunjin ;
Wang, Xiaoming ;
Yang, Yubo ;
Han, Ping ;
Wang, Jia .
BMC Urology, 2017, 17
[6]   Infective complications after retrograde intrarenal surgery: a new standardized classification system [J].
Berardinelli, Francesco ;
De Francesco, Piergustavo ;
Marchioni, Michele ;
Cera, Nicoletta ;
Proietti, Silvia ;
Hennessey, Derek ;
Dalpiaz, Orietta ;
Cracco, Cecilia ;
Scoffone, Cesare ;
Schips, Luigi ;
Giusti, Guido ;
Cindolo, Luca .
INTERNATIONAL UROLOGY AND NEPHROLOGY, 2016, 48 (11) :1757-1762
[7]   The Clinical Research Office of the Endourological Society Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy Global Study: Nephrolithotomy in 189 Patients with Solitary Kidneys [J].
Bucuras, Viorel ;
Gopalakrishnam, Ganesh ;
Wolf, J. Stuart, Jr. ;
Sun, Yinghao ;
Bianchi, Giampaolo ;
Erdogru, Tibet ;
de la Rosette, Jean .
JOURNAL OF ENDOUROLOGY, 2012, 26 (04) :336-341
[8]   Functional Outcomes Following Percutaneous Surgery in the Solitary Kidney [J].
Canes, David ;
Hegarty, Nicholas J. ;
Kamoi, Kazumi ;
Haber, Georges-Pascal ;
Berger, Andre ;
Aron, Monish ;
Desai, Mihir M. .
JOURNAL OF UROLOGY, 2009, 181 (01) :154-160
[9]   Systemic inflammatory response syndrome after percutaneous nephrolithotomy: An assessment of risk factors [J].
Chen, Liang ;
Xu, Qing-Quan ;
Li, Jian-Xing ;
Xiong, Liu-Lin ;
Wang, Xiao-Feng ;
Huang, Xiao-Bo .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF UROLOGY, 2008, 15 (12) :1025-1028
[10]   Minimally Invasive Tract in Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy for Renal Stones [J].
Cheng, Fan ;
Yu, Weimin ;
Zhang, Xiaobin ;
Yang, Sixing ;
Xia, Yue ;
Ruan, Yuan .
JOURNAL OF ENDOUROLOGY, 2010, 24 (10) :1579-1582