Clinical coordination in accountable care organizations: A qualitative study

Background: Accountable care organizations (ACOs) are becoming a common payment and delivery model. Despite widespread interest, little empirical research has examined what efforts or strategies ACOs are using to change care and reduce costs. Knowledge of ACOs' clinical efforts can provide important context for understanding ACO performance, particularly to distinguish arenas where ACOs have and have not attempted care transformation. Purpose: The aim of the study was to understand ACOs' efforts to change clinical care during the first 18 months of ACO contracts. Methods: We conducted semistructured interviews between July and December 2013. Our sample includes ACOs that began performance contracts in 2012, including Medicare Shared Savings Program and Pioneer participants, stratified across key factors. In total, we conducted interviews with executives from 30 ACOs. Iterative qualitative analysis identified common patterns and themes. Results: ACOs in the first year of performance contracts are commonly focusing on four areas: first, transforming primary care through increased access and team-based care; second, reducing avoidable emergency department use; third, strengthening practice-based care management; and fourth, developing new boundary spanner roles and activities. ACOs were doing little around transforming specialty care, acute and postacute care, or standardizing care across practices during the first 18 months of ACO performance contracts. Practice Implications: Results suggest that cost reductions associated with ACOs in the first years of contracts may be related to primary care. Although in the long termmany hope ACOs will achieve coordination across awide array of care settings and providers, in the short term providers under ACO contracts are focused largely on primary care- related strategies. Our work provides a template of the common areas of clinical activity in the first years ofACO contracts, which may be informative to providers considering becoming an ACO. Further research will be needed to understand how these strategies are associated with performance.