When to replicate systematic reviews of interventions: consensus checklist

被引：51

作者：

Tugwell, Peter ^{[1
,2
,3
,4
]}

Welch, Vivian Andrea ^{[2
,4
]}

Karunananthan, Sathya ^{[3
]}

Maxwell, Lara J. ^{[3
]}

Akl, Elie A. ^{[5
]}

Avey, Marc T. ^{[6
]}

Bhutta, Zulfiqar A. ^{[7
]}

Brouwers, Melissa C. ^{[4
]}

Clark, Jocalyn P. ^{[8
]}

Cook, Sophie ^{[9
]}

Cuervo, Luis Gabriel ^{[10
]}

Curran, Janet Agnes ^{[11
]}

Ghogomu, Elizabeth Tanjong ^{[2
]}

Graham, Ian G. ^{[3
,4
]}

Grimshaw, Jeremy M. ^{[1
,3
]}

Hutton, Brian ^{[3
]}

Ioannidis, John P. A. ^{[12
,13
]}

Jordan, Zoe ^{[14
]}

Jull, Janet Elizabeth ^{[15
]}

Kristjansson, Elizabeth ^{[16
]}

Langlois, Etienne V. ^{[17
]}

Little, Julian ^{[4
]}

Lyddiatt, Anne

Martin, Janet E. ^{[18
,19
]}

Marusic, Ana ^{[20
]}

Mbuagbaw, Lawrence ^{[21
]}

Moher, David ^{[3
]}

Morton, Rachael L. ^{[22
]}

Nasser, Mona ^{[23
]}

Page, Matthew J. ^{[24
]}

Pardo, Jordi Pardo ^{[25
]}

Petkovic, Jennifer ^{[2
]}

Petticrew, Mark ^{[26
]}

Pigott, Terri ^{[27
]}

Pottie, Kevin ^{[28
]}

Rada, Gabriel ^{[29
]}

Rader, Tamara ^{[30
]}

Riddle, Alison Y. ^{[2
]}

Rothstein, Hannah ^{[31
]}

Schuneman, Holger J. ^{[32
]}

Shamseer, Larissa ^{[3
,4
]}

Shea, Beverley J. ^{[4
]}

Simeon, Rosiane ^{[33
]}

Siontis, Konstantinos C. ^{[34
]}

Smith, Maureen

Soares-Weiser, Karla ^{[35
]}

Thavorn, Kednapa ^{[3
,4
]}

Thavorn, David Tovey ^{[35
]}

Vachon, Brigitte ^{[36
]}

Valentine, Jeffery ^{[37
]}

机构：

[1] Univ Ottawa, Dept Med, 501 Smyth Rd,Room L1227, Ottawa, ON K1H 8L6, Canada

[2] Bruyere Res Inst, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[3] Ottawa Hosp, Clin Epidemiol Program, Res Inst, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[4] Univ Ottawa, Sch Epidemiol & Publ Hlth, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[5] Amer Univ Beirut, Dept Internal Med, Beirut, Lebanon

[6] Publ Hlth Agcy Canada, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[7] Hosp Sick Children, Toronto, ON, Canada

[8] Univ Toronto, Dept Med, Toronto, ON, Canada

[9] BMJ Editorial, London, England

[10] Pan Amer Hlth Org PAHO WHO, Unit Hlth Serv & Access, Washington, DC USA

[11] Dalhousie Univ, Fac Hlth, Halifax, NS, Canada

[12] Stanford Univ, Dept Med, Stanford Prevent Res Ctr, Stanford, CA 94305 USA

[13] Stanford Univ, Dept Epidemiol & Populat Hlth, Stanford, CA 94305 USA

[14] Univ Adelaide, Fac Hlth & Med Sci, JBI, Adelaide, SA, Australia

[15] Queens Univ, Sch Rehabil Therapy, Kingston, ON, Canada

[16] Fac Social Sci, Sch Psychol, Ctr Res Educ & Community Serv, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[17] WHO, Partnership Maternal Newborn & Child Hlth PMNCH, Geneva, Switzerland

[18] Western Univ, Dept Anesthesia & Perioperat Med, London, ON, Canada

[19] Western Univ, Dept Epidemiol & Biostat, London, ON, Canada

[20] Univ Split, Dept Res Biomed & Hlth, Sch Med, Split, Croatia

[21] McMaster Univ, Dept Clin Epidemiol & Biostat, Hamilton, ON, Canada

[22] Univ Sydney, NHMRC Clin Trials Ctr, Sydney, NSW, Australia

[23] Univ Plymouth, Fac Hlth, Plymouth, Devon, England

[24] Monash Univ, Sch Publ Hlth & Prevent Med, Melbourne, Vic, Australia

[25] Ottawa Hosp, Cochrane Musculoskeletal Grp, Res Inst, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[26] London Sch Hyg & Trop Med, Fac Publ Hlth & Policy, London, England

[27] Georgia State Univ, Coll Educ & Human Dev, Atlanta, GA 30303 USA

[28] Univ Ottawa, Dept Family Med, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[29] Epistemonikos Fdn, Santiago, Chile

[30] Canadian Agcy Drugs & Technol Hlth, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[31] Baruch Coll, Narendra Paul Loomba Dept Management, New York, NY USA

[32] McMaster Univ, Cochrane Canada & McMaster GRADE Ctr, Dept Hlth Res Methods Evidence & Impact, Hamilton, ON, Canada

[33] Univ Ottawa, Interdisciplinary Sch Hlth Sci, Populat Hlth, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[34] Mayo Clin, Dept Cardiovasc Med, Rochester, MN USA

[35] Cochrane, London, England

[36] Univ Montreal, Sch Rehabil, Fac Med, Montreal, PQ, Canada

[37] Univ Louisville, Louisville, KY 40292 USA

[38] Univ Ottawa, Dept Mech Engn, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[39] Univ Ottawa, Cardiovasc Res Methods Ctr, Heart Inst, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[40] George Mason Univ, Fairfax, VA 22030 USA

[41] Campbell Collaborat, Oslo, Norway

来源：

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL | 2020年 / 370卷

关键词：

MASS-PRODUCTION; HEALTH;

D O I：

10.1136/bmj.m2864

中图分类号：

R5 [内科学];

学科分类号：

1002 ; 100201 ;

摘要：

Replication is an essential part of the scientific method, yet replication of systematic reviews is too often overlooked, and done unnecessarily or poorly. Excessive replication (doing the same study repeatedly) is unethical and a cause of research wastage. This article provides consensus based guidance on when to replicate and not replicate systematic reviews.

引用

页数：8

共 35 条

[11] Hoomans T, 2012, AHRQ METHODS EFFECTI
[12] The Mass Production of Redundant, Misleading, and Conflicted Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses
Ioannidis, John P. A.
[J]. MILBANK QUARTERLY, 2016, 94 (03) : 485 - 514
[13] Jadad AR, 1997, CAN MED ASSOC J, V156, P1411
[14] The Cochrane HPV vaccine review was incomplete and ignored important evidence of bias
Jorgensen, Lars
Gotzsche, Peter C.
Jefferson, Tom
[J]. BMJ EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE, 2018, 23 (05) : 165 - 168
[15] Taking an integrated knowledge translation approach in research to develop the CONSORT-Equity 2017 reporting guideline: an observational study
Jull, Janet
Graham, Ian D.
Kristjansson, Elizabeth
Moher, David
Petkovic, Jennifer
Yoganathan, Manosila
Tugwell, Peter
Welch, Vivian A.
Armstrong, Rebecca
Baird, Sarah
Boyer, Yvonne
Cuervo, Luis Gabriel
Greer-Smith, Regina
Lyddiatt, Anne
McGowan, Jessie
Mbuagbaw, Lawrence
Pantoja, Tomas
Shea, Beverly
Robberstad, Bjarne
White, Howard
Wells, George
[J]. BMJ OPEN, 2019, 9 (07):
[16] Comparison of two independent systematic reviews of trials of recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2): the Yale Open Data Access Medtronic Project
Low, Jeffrey
Ross, Joseph S.
Ritchie, Jessica D.
Gross, Cary P.
Lehman, Richard
Lin, Haiqun
Fu, Rongwei
Stewart, Lesley A.
Krumholz, Harlan M.
[J]. SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS, 2017, 6
[17] Value of Information: A Tool to Improve Research Prioritization and Reduce Waste
Minelli, Cosetta
Baio, Gianluca
[J]. PLOS MEDICINE, 2015, 12 (09):
[18] Systematic reviews: when is an update an update?
Moher, D
Tsertsvadze, A
[J]. LANCET, 2006, 367 (9514) : 881 - 883
[19] Guidance for Developers of Health Research Reporting Guidelines
Moher, David
Schulz, Kenneth F.
Simera, Iveta
Altman, Douglas G.
[J]. PLOS MEDICINE, 2010, 7 (02)
[20] Multiple systematic reviews: methods for assessing discordances of results
Moja, Lorenzo
Pilar Fernandez del Rio, M.
Banzi, Rita
Cusi, Cristina
D'Amico, Roberto
Liberati, Alessandro
Lodi, Giovanni
Lucenteforte, Ersilia
Minozzi, Silvia
Pecoraro, Valentina
Virgili, Gianni
Parmelli, Elena
[J]. INTERNAL AND EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 2012, 7 (06) : 563 - 568

← 1 2 3 4 →