Health-related quality of life: a retrospective study on local vs. microvascular reconstruction in patients with oral cancer

BackgroundNew medicinal and surgical oncological treatment strategies not only improve overall survival rates but continually increase the importance of Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQOL). The purpose of this retrospective cross-sectional study was to analyze HRQOL of patients with oral squamous cell carcinoma after ablative surgery and to evaluate predictive factors for HRQOL outcome.MethodsThe study included 88 patients with histologically confirmed oral squamous cell carcinoma of whom 42 had undergone local reconstruction (LR) and 46 microvascular reconstruction (MVR). During follow-up, all patients completed the University of Washington Quality of Life Questionnaire (UW-QOL) containing 12 targeted questions about the head and neck. Descriptive analyses were made for the tumor site, the T-stage, and adjuvant therapies. HRQOL was compared between the LR and the MVR group with parametric tests. Further analyses were impact of the tumor site, the T-status, and the time from surgery to survey on HRQOL. Statistics also included multivariate correlations and different interaction effects.ResultsHRQOL in the LR group was very good' with 84.313.7 and good' in the MVR group with 73.316.5 points. The physical domains swallowing (p=0.00), chewing (p=0.00), speech (p=0.01), taste (p=0.01), and pain (p=0.04) were significantly worse in the MVR group. An increase in the T-status had a significant negative effect on swallowing (p=0.01), chewing (p=0.01), speech (p=0.03), recreation (p=0.05), and shoulder (p=0.01) in both groups. Regarding the tumor site and subsequent loss of HRQOL, patients with squamous cell carcinoma on the floor of the mouth had significantly worse results in the categories pain (p=0.002), speech (p=0.002), swallowing (p=0.03), activity (p=0.02), and recreation (p=0.01) than patients with tumors in the buccal mucosa. Speech (p=0.03) and pain (p=0.01) had improved 1year after surgery.Conclusion Patients with flap reconstruction because of oral squamous cell carcinoma showed very good overall HRQOL. Outcomes for microvascular reconstruction were good, even in the case of larger defects. The T-status is a predictor for HRQOL. Swallowing, chewing, speaking, taste, and pain were the most important issues in our cohort. Implementing HRQOL questionnaires for the assessment of quality of life could further increase the treatment quality of patients with oral cancer.