Spatial and temporal variation in animal aggregations may be due to variation in the presence of cues for aggregation (or disaggregation) or to variation in the receptivity of the animal to a particular cue or suite of cues. Spiny lobsters, Panulirus argus, forage solitarily but are often found aggregated in their diurnal shelters. An important proximate cause of aggregation among spiny lobsters is a scent they produce that influences shelter choice by conspecifics. We examined how variability in the presence of, or response to, such a chemical cue may contribute to diel shifts in sociality among spiny lobsters. We conducted a series of Y-maze shelter choice experiments using lobsters that were either maintained under altered dark:light schedules in the experimental arena or under natural lighting in the head tanks. Lobsters that were maintained on a light schedule 8 h later than normal chose shelters at their dawn (corresponding to the middle of the night for lobsters in the head tanks); however, their choices of shelter were not influenced by scents of conspecifics. Lobsters that were maintained on a schedule 8 h earlier than normal chose shelters in the middle of their night (corresponding to dawn for the lobsters in the head tanks). Their choices of shelter were significantly influenced by conspecific scents. These results suggest that the chemical cues for aggregation, released by spiny lobsters, are present discontinuously, that spiny lobsters are influenced by conspecific odours continuously, and that aggregation is controlled by temporal variation in the presence of a chemical cue. (C) 2000 The Association for the Study of Animal Behaviour.