Biopsy versus resection for high-grade glioma

被引:8
作者
Hart, M. G. [1 ]
Grant, G. R. L. [2 ]
Solyom, E. F. [2 ]
Grant, R. [3 ]
机构
[1] Addenbrookes Hosp, Acad Div Neurosurg, Dept Clin Neurosci, Box 167, Cambridge CB2 0QQ, England
[2] Univ St Andrews, St Andrews, Fife, Scotland
[3] Western Gen Hosp, ECNO, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland
来源
COCHRANE DATABASE OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS | 2019年 / 06期
关键词
Biopsy [*methods; Brain Neoplasms [pathology; *surgery; Craniotomy; Glioma [pathology; Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic; Risk; Stereotaxic Techniques; Humans; MALIGNANT GLIOMA; GLIOBLASTOMA-MULTIFORME; RADIATION-THERAPY; INTRACRANIAL TUMORS; SURGICAL RESECTION; PROGNOSTIC-FACTORS; FOLLOW-UP; SURVIVAL; SURGERY; CHEMOTHERAPY;
D O I
10.1002/14651858.CD002034.pub2
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Background This is an update of the original review published in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews Issue 1, 2000 and updated in 2003, 2007 and 2010. People with a presumed high-grade glioma (HGG) identified by clinical evaluation and radiological investigation have two initial surgical options: biopsy or resection. In certain situations, such as severe raised intracranial pressure, surgical resection is clinically indicated. Where surgical resection is not feasible, biopsy is the only reasonable option. Most people fall somewhere between these extremes, and in such circumstances it is uncertain which procedure is the best surgical option for the patient. Opinion is divided regarding the relative risks and benefits of each procedure. Objectives To estimate the clinical effectiveness of surgical resection compared to biopsy in people with a new presumptive diagnosis of HGG. Search methods We updated our searches of the following databases to 12 September 2018: CochraneCentral Register ofControlledTrials (CENTRAL), MEDLINE, and Embase. We also handsearched the Journal of Neuro-Oncology and Neuro-Oncology from 2010 to 2018 (including all conference abstracts). Selection criteria We included randomised controlled trials (RCTs) involving people of all ages with a presumed diagnosis of HGG based upon clinical and radiological investigation. Interventions included any form of biopsy or resection. Surgery was at the time of initial presentation and not for recurrence. Data collection and analysis Two reviews authors independently assessed the search results for relevance and undertook critical appraisal according to prespecified guidelines. Outcomemeasures included survival, time to progression/progression-free survival, quality of life, symptom control, adverse events, and mortality. Main results We identified a single RCT of biopsy versus resection in presumed HGG. No other articles met the inclusion criteria. Personal communication revealed that an RCT of biopsy versus resection in elderly people with HGG is underway. Further communication as part of this 2018 update revealed that the results of this study are due to be published in 2019. Authors 'conclusions There is no high-quality evidence on biopsy versus resection forHGG that can be used to guide management. The single included RCT was of inadequate methodology to reach reliable conclusions. Further large, multicentred RCTs are required to conclusively answer the question of whether biopsy or resection is the best initial surgical management for HGG.
引用
收藏
页数:24
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Extent of surgical resection of high-grade glioma among the elderly Reply
    Badhiwala, Jetan H.
    Almenawer, Saleh A.
    NEURO-ONCOLOGY, 2015, 17 (06) : 903 - 904
  • [32] How I do it? Anatomical multifocal high-grade glioma resection
    Yang, Zixiao
    Song, Jianping
    Zhu, Wei
    ACTA NEUROCHIRURGICA, 2021, 163 (04) : 953 - 957
  • [33] The PROGRAM study: awake mapping versus asleep mapping versus no mapping for high-grade glioma resections: study protocol for an international multicenter prospective three-arm cohort study
    Gerritsen, Jasper Kees Wim
    Dirven, Clemens Maria Franciscus
    De Vleeschouwer, Steven
    Schucht, Philippe
    Jungk, Christine
    Krieg, Sandro M.
    Nahed, Brian Vala
    Berger, Mitchel Stuart
    Broekman, Marike Lianne Daphne
    Vincent, Arnaud Jean Pierre Edouard
    BMJ OPEN, 2021, 11 (07):
  • [34] Re-resection for recurrent high-grade glioma in the setting of re-irradiation: more is not always better
    Palmer, Joshua D.
    Siglin, Joshua
    Yamoah, Kosj
    Dan, Tu
    Champ, Colin E.
    Bar-Ad, Voichita
    Werner-Wasik, Maria
    Evans, James J.
    Kim, Lyndon
    Glass, Jon
    Farrell, Christopher
    Andrews, David W.
    Shi, Wenyin
    JOURNAL OF NEURO-ONCOLOGY, 2015, 124 (02) : 215 - 221
  • [35] Optimizing the Extent of Resection and Minimizing the Morbidity in Insular High-Grade Glioma Surgery by High-Field lntraoperative MRI Guidance
    Chen, Li-feng
    Yang, Yang
    Ma, Xiao-dong
    Yu, Xin-guang
    Gui, Qiu-ping
    Xu, Bai-nan
    Zhou, Ding-biao
    TURKISH NEUROSURGERY, 2017, 27 (05) : 696 - 706
  • [36] Prognostic factors and survival study in high-grade glioma in the elderly
    Alvarez de Eulate-Beramendi, Sayoa
    Antonio Alvarez-Vega, Marco
    Balbin, Milagros
    Sanchez-Pitiot, Ana
    Vallina-Alvarez, Aitana
    Martino-Gonzalez, Juan
    BRITISH JOURNAL OF NEUROSURGERY, 2016, 30 (03) : 330 - 336
  • [37] Radiosurgery reirradiation for high-grade glioma recurrence: a retrospective analysis
    Pinzi, Valentina
    Orsi, Chiara
    Marchetti, Marcello
    Milanesi, Ida Maddalena
    Bianchi, Livia Corinna
    DiMeco, Francesco
    Cuccarini, Valeria
    Farinotti, Mariangela
    Ferroli, Paolo
    Finocchiaro, Gaetano
    Franzini, Angelo
    Fumagalli, MariaLuisa
    Silvani, Antonio
    Fariselli, Laura
    NEUROLOGICAL SCIENCES, 2015, 36 (08) : 1431 - 1440
  • [38] Reoperation for Recurrent High-Grade Glioma: A Current Perspective of the Literature
    Hervey-Jumper, Shawn L.
    Berger, Mitchel S.
    NEUROSURGERY, 2014, 75 (05) : 491 - 499
  • [39] Radioimmunotherapy for high-grade glioma
    De Bonis, Pasquale
    Lofrese, Giorgio
    Anile, Carmelo
    Pompucci, Angelo
    Vigo, Vera
    Mangiola, Annunziato
    IMMUNOTHERAPY, 2013, 5 (06) : 647 - 659
  • [40] Cerebellar High-Grade Glioma: A Translationally Oriented Review of the Literature
    Raghu, Ashley L. B.
    Chen, Jason A.
    Valdes, Pablo A.
    Essayed, Walid Ibn
    Claus, Elizabeth
    Arnaout, Omar
    Smith, Timothy R.
    Chiocca, E. Antonio
    Peruzzi, Pier Paolo
    Bernstock, Joshua D.
    CANCERS, 2023, 15 (01)