Sublimated or castrated psychoanalysis? Adorno's critique of the revisionist psychoanalysis: An introduction to 'The Revisionist Psychoanalysis'

被引:9
作者
Lee, Nan-Nan [1 ]
机构
[1] St Xavier Univ, Chicago, IL 60655 USA
关键词
Theodor Adorno; Critical Theory; neo-Freudianism; psychoanalysis; social psychology;
D O I
10.1177/0191453713520162
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
In The Revisionist Psychoanalysis', Adorno criticizes the neo-Freudian psychoanalysis for losing the critical edge of Freud's theory with regard to social critique. Neo-Freudians whom Adorno calls revisionists' criticize Freud for his mechanical' views of the human psyche and for his over-emphasis on sexual libido. They reverse Freud's dictum - where id was, there ego shall be' - by stressing the importance of development of the ego, and thus that of its adaptive functions. For revisionists, the aim of psychoanalytic practice is to help analysands be better adapted to their social environment. According to Adorno, the revisionist psychoanalysis is suspected of conformism, and implicitly advocating an ideology that what is existent is the best of all possible worlds. The emphasis on adaptation actually weakens the ego instead of strengthening it - leaving it vulnerable to the whim of social conditions, and that of instinctual impulses. Most importantly, it weakens individuals' ability to think critically and makes them susceptible to ideological and psychological manipulation against their own rational interests.
引用
收藏
页码:309 / 338
页数:30
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] INTRODUCTION: QUEERING FREUD DIFFERENTLY: RADICAL PSYCHOANALYSIS AND ETHNOGRAPHY IN THE 1970s-1980s
    Herzog, Dagmar
    PSYCHOANALYSIS AND HISTORY, 2020, 22 (01) : 1 - 14
  • [42] SURREALIST PSYCHOPOLITICS: MARXISM, PSYCHOANALYSIS, ARTISTIC AVANT-GARDE AND CRITIQUE OF PSYCHOLOGY
    Pavon Cuellar, David
    REVISTA DE CIENCIAS SOCIALES-COSTA RICA, 2018, (160): : 119 - 135
  • [43] DISCUSSION OF NEIL ALTMAN'S PAPER, 'PSYCHOANALYSIS AND WAR'
    Altman, Neil
    Cushman, Phil
    Goldsmith, Marlene
    Hartman, Stephen
    Hollander, Nancy
    Lesser, Ronnie
    Lotto, David
    Mccarroll, Jennifer
    Peoples, Karen
    Riethmiller, Rob
    Samuels, Andrew
    Soldz, Stephen
    Stopford, Annie
    PSYCHOTHERAPY AND POLITICS INTERNATIONAL, 2007, 5 (03) : 184 - 214
  • [44] Countering psychoanalysis: Irene Nemirovsky's Master of souls
    Lussone, Teresa Manuela
    REVUE ITALIENNE D'ETUDES FRANCAISES, 2019, (09):
  • [45] For a critique of violence in psychoanalysis: from the original violence of the law to its tragic processing
    Cabrera Sanchez, Jose
    TRANS-FORM-ACAO, 2019, 42 (01): : 101 - 121
  • [46] Lacan's "electronic machine": Alan Turing and psychoanalysis
    Saint-Jevin, Alexandre
    EVOLUTION PSYCHIATRIQUE, 2017, 82 (04): : 761 - 773
  • [47] Misinterpreting Winnicott: Axel Honneth's Use of Psychoanalysis
    Whitebook, Joel
    PSYCHE-ZEITSCHRIFT FUR PSYCHOANALYSE UND IHRE ANWENDUNGEN, 2022, 76 (02) : 97 - 138
  • [48] Freud's dreams of reason: the Kantian structure of psychoanalysis
    Tauber, Alfred I.
    HISTORY OF THE HUMAN SCIENCES, 2009, 22 (04) : 1 - 29
  • [49] From Freud's Psychoanalysis to Philosophical Pathology of Culture
    Kyslan, Peter
    FILOZOFIA, 2023, 78 (06): : 474 - 491
  • [50] On Causes of Teddy's Tragedy in Shutter Island by Psychoanalysis
    吴彦凤
    海外英语, 2013, (03) : 197 - 198