Evaluation of cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) as vehicles for intracellular delivery of antisense peptide nucleic acid (PNA)

Cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) are characterized by their ability to be internalized in mammalian cells. To investigate the relative potency of CPPs as carriers of medicinally relevant cargo, a positive read-out assay based on the ability of a peptide nucleic acid (PNA) oligomer to promote correct expression of a recombinant luciferase gene was employed. Seven different CPPs were included in the study: Transportan, oligo-arginine (R7-9), pTat, Penetratin, KFF, SynB3, and NLS. The CPP-PNA conjugates were synthesized by different conjugation chemistries: continuous synthesis, maleimide coupling, and ester or disulfide linkage. Under serum-free conditions PNA-SS-Transportan-amide (ortho)-PNA was found to be the most potent conjugate, resulting in maximum luciferase signal at a concentration of 1-2 mu M. (D-Arg)(9)-PNA showed optimal efficacy at 5 AM but gave rise to only one-third of the luciferase signal obtained with the Transportan conjugate. The pTat- and KFF-PNA conjugates showed significantly lower efficacy. The penetratin-, SynB3-. and NLS-PNA conjugates showed only minimal or no activity. Serum was found to have a drastic negative impact on CPP-driven cellular uptake. PNA-SS-Transportan-acid (ortho) and (D-Arg) 9-PNA were least sensitive to the presence of serum. Both the chemical nature and, in the case of Transportan, the position of the peptide PNA coupling were found to have a major impact on the transport capacity of the peptides. However, no simple relationship between linker type and antisense activity of the conjugates could be deduced from the data.