Do Plants Feel Pain?

被引:6
作者
Hamilton, Adam [1 ]
McBrayer, Justin [2 ]
机构
[1] Perfect Day Inc, Emeryville, CA 94608 USA
[2] Ft Lewis Coll, Durango, CO 81301 USA
来源
DISPUTATIO-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY | 2020年 / 12卷 / 56期
关键词
Plants; pain; moral patient; phenomenal consciousness; qualia; NEUROBIOLOGY; ATTRIBUTION; ANIMALS; BRAIN; MIND;
D O I
10.2478/disp-2020-0003
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
Many people are attracted to the idea that plants experience phenomenal conscious states like pain, sensory awareness, or emotions like fear. If true, this would have wide-ranging moral implications for human behavior, including land development, farming, vegetarianism, and more. Determining whether plants have minds relies on the work of both empirical disciplines and philosophy. Epistemology should settle the standards for evidence of other minds, and science should inform our judgment about whether any plants meet those standards. We argue that evidence for other minds comes either from testimony, behavior, anatomy/physiology, or phylogeny. However, none of these provide evidence that plants have conscious mental states. Therefore, we conclude that there is no evidence that plants have minds in the sense relevant for morality.
引用
收藏
页码:71 / 98
页数:28
相关论文
共 61 条
[1]   Learning in Plants: Lessons from Mimosa pudica [J].
Abramson, Charles I. ;
Chicas-Mosier, Ana M. .
FRONTIERS IN PSYCHOLOGY, 2016, 7
[2]   Plant neurobiology: no brain, no gain? [J].
Alpi, Amedeo ;
Amrhein, Nikolaus ;
Bertl, Adam ;
Blatt, Michael R. ;
Blumwald, Eduardo ;
Cervone, Felice ;
Dainty, Jack ;
De Michelis, Maria Ida ;
Epstein, Emanuel ;
Galston, Arthur W. ;
Goldsmith, Mary Helen M. ;
Hawes, Chris ;
Hell, Ruediger ;
Hetherington, Alistair ;
Hofte, Herman ;
Juergens, Gerd ;
Leaver, Chris J. ;
Moroni, Anna ;
Murphy, Angus ;
Oparka, Karl ;
Perata, Pierdomenico ;
Quader, Hartmut ;
Rausch, Thomas ;
Ritzenthaler, Christophe ;
Rivetta, Alberto ;
Robinson, David G. ;
Sanders, Dale ;
Scheres, Ben ;
Schumacher, Karin ;
Sentenac, Herve ;
Slayman, Clifford L. ;
Soave, Carlo ;
Somerville, Chris ;
Taiz, Lincoln ;
Thiel, Gerhard ;
Wagner, Richard .
TRENDS IN PLANT SCIENCE, 2007, 12 (04) :135-136
[3]   Plants respond to leaf vibrations caused by insect herbivore chewing [J].
Appel, H. M. ;
Cocroft, R. B. .
OECOLOGIA, 2014, 175 (04) :1257-1266
[4]   Plant synapses: actin-based domains for cell-to-cell communication [J].
Baluska, F ;
Volkmann, D ;
Menzel, D .
TRENDS IN PLANT SCIENCE, 2005, 10 (03) :106-111
[5]   Polar transport of auxin: carrier-mediated flux across the plasma membrane or neurotransmitter-like secretion? [J].
Baluska, F ;
Samaj, J ;
Menzel, D .
TRENDS IN CELL BIOLOGY, 2003, 13 (06) :282-285
[6]  
Baluska F, 2004, BIOLOGIA, V59, P7
[7]   The architecture of polarized cell growth: the unique status of elongating plant cells [J].
Baluska, F ;
Wojtaszek, P ;
Volkmann, D ;
Barlow, P .
BIOESSAYS, 2003, 25 (06) :569-576
[8]  
Baron-Cohen S, 2001, INT REV RES MENT RET, V23, P169
[9]  
Bentham Jeremy., 1979, An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation
[10]  
Bird Christopher., 1973, The Secret Life of Plants