Willingness to pay for a quality-adjusted life year: Implications for societal health care resource allocation

Background. Health-state preferences can be combined with willingness-to-pay (WTP) data to calculate WTP per quality-adjusted life year (QALY). The WTP/QALY ratios provide insight into societal valuations of expenditures for medical interventions. Methods. The authors measured preferences for current health in 3 patient populations (N = 391) using standard gamble, time trade-off, visual analog scale, and WTP then they calculated WTP/QALY ratios. The ratios were compared with several proposed cost/QALY cost-effectiveness ratio thresholds, the value-of-life literature, and with WTP/QALY ratios derived from published preference research. Results. Mean WTP/QALY ratios ranged from $12,500 to $32,200 (2003 $US). All values were below most published cost-effectiveness ratio thresholds, below the ratio from a prototypic medical treatment covered by Medicare (i.e., renal dialysis), and below ratios from the value-of-life literature, The WTP/QALY ratios were similar to those calculated from published preference data for patients with symptomatic menopause, dentofacial deformities, asthma, or dermatologic disorders. Conclusions. WTP/QALY ratios calculated using preference data collected from diverse populations are lower than most proposed thresholds for determining what is "cost-effective," Current proposed cost-effectiveness ratio thresholds may overestimate the willingness of society to pay for medical interventions.