To cause or to let it happen

被引:0
作者
Miguel, Hernan [1 ]
Paruelo, Jorge [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Buenos Aires, RA-1053 Buenos Aires, DF, Argentina
来源
ANDAMIOS | 2007年 / 4卷 / 07期
关键词
causation; omission; preventor; couterfactuals; events;
D O I
10.29092/uacm.v4i7.312
中图分类号
C [社会科学总论];
学科分类号
03 ; 0303 ;
摘要
Among the topics covered by discussion on causation between events is causation that involves omissions. If, by having taken precautions, the robbery would not have occurred, then the omission of not having taken precautions is the cause for the robbery On the other hand, if the robbery did not take place because of the precautions taken, we say that those precautions are a preventor of the robbery. Some kind of mirror relationship has been suggested from which derives that not taking precautions and removing them is equivalent. In this paper, such an equivalence is analyzed and it is shown that it has no support for the cases which involve states of affairs. Analyzing causation involves dealing with causation by omission and causation of omission. In the first case, omission to take precautions is the cause of a certain disaster. In the second, having taken such precautions is the cause for not obtaining the mentioned disaster: to take precautions is a preventor of the disaster. It has been pointed out that there exists a mirror relationship between omissions and preventors, giving as a consequence that omitting to establish preventors should be equivalent to removing preventors previously provided. In this paper we analyze this equivalence, and conclude that it cannot be supported when states of affairs take place in the role of causes or of effects.
引用
收藏
页码:7 / +
页数:13
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Can parts cause their wholes?
    Friend, Toby
    SYNTHESE, 2019, 196 (12) : 5061 - 5082
  • [32] Reichenbachian common cause systems
    Hofer-Szabó, G
    Rédei, M
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF THEORETICAL PHYSICS, 2004, 43 (7-8) : 1819 - 1826
  • [33] Mental disorder as the cause of a crime
    Buchanan, Alec
    Zonana, Howard
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LAW AND PSYCHIATRY, 2009, 32 (03) : 142 - 146
  • [34] Would-Cause Semantics
    Dowe, Phil
    PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 2009, 76 (05) : 701 - 711
  • [35] Cause and Effect in Antidiscrimination Law
    Bavli, Hillel J.
    IOWA LAW REVIEW, 2021, 106 (02) : 483 - 554
  • [36] Necessary versus Probable Cause
    Lisa A. Reed
    Journal of Philosophical Logic, 1999, 28 : 289 - 326
  • [37] Necessary versus probable cause
    Reed, LA
    JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHICAL LOGIC, 1999, 28 (03) : 289 - 326
  • [38] Can parts cause their wholes?
    Toby Friend
    Synthese, 2019, 196 : 5061 - 5082
  • [39] Detection strategies for elevated lipoprotein(a): will implementation let the genie out of the bottle?
    Loh, Wann Jia
    Watts, Gerald F.
    CURRENT OPINION IN ENDOCRINOLOGY DIABETES AND OBESITY, 2023, 30 (02) : 94 - 102
  • [40] Let's Get "REAL": A Collaborative Group Therapy for Moral injury
    Smigelsky, Melissa A.
    Malott, Jesse
    Parker, Ryan
    Check, Carter
    Rappaport, Brad
    Ward, Steffanie
    JOURNAL OF HEALTH CARE CHAPLAINCY, 2022, 28 : S42 - S56