A discussion of the merits of random man not excluded and likelihood ratios

被引：37

作者：

Buckleton, John ^{[1
]}

Curran, James ^{[2
]}

机构：

[1] ESR, Auckland, New Zealand

[2] Univ Auckland, Dept Stat, Auckland 1, New Zealand

来源：

FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL-GENETICS | 2008年 / 2卷 / 04期

关键词：

DNA; Mixtures; Likelihood ratios; Random man not excluded; Cumulative probability of inclusion;

D O I：

10.1016/j.fsigen.2008.05.005

中图分类号：

Q3 [遗传学];

学科分类号：

071007 ; 090102 ;

摘要：

DNA mixture interpretation is undertaken either by calculating a LR or an exclusion probability (RMNE or its complement CPI). Debate exists as to which has the greater claim. The merits and drawbacks of the two approaches are discussed. We conclude that the two matters that appear to have real force are: (1) LRs are more difficult to present in court and (2) the RMNE statistic wastes information that should be utilised. (C) 2008 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.

引用

页码：343 / 348

页数：6

共 17 条

[1] DNA PROFILE MATCH PROBABILITY CALCULATION - HOW TO ALLOW FOR POPULATION STRATIFICATION, RELATEDNESS, DATABASE SELECTION AND SINGLE BANDS
BALDING, DJ
NICHOLS, RA
[J]. FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL, 1994, 64 (2-3) : 125 - 140
[2] PENDULUM - a guideline-based approach to the interpretation of STR mixtures
Bill, M
Gill, P
Curran, J
Clayton, T
Pinchin, R
Healy, M
Buckleton, J
[J]. FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL, 2005, 148 (2-3) : 181 - 189
[3] Is the 2p rule always conservative?
Buckleton, J
Triggs, C
[J]. FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL, 2006, 159 (2-3) : 206 - 209
[4] Buckleton J.S., 2004, DNA EVIDENCE
[5] Towards understanding the effect of uncertainty in the number of contributors to DNA stains
Buckleton, John S.
Curran, James M.
Gill, Peter
[J]. FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL-GENETICS, 2007, 1 (01) : 20 - 28
[6] Analysis and interpretation of mixed forensic stains using DNA STR profiling
Clayton, TM
Whitaker, JP
Sparkes, R
Gill, P
[J]. FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL, 1998, 91 (01) : 55 - 70
[7] Curran JM, 1999, J FORENSIC SCI, V44, P987
[8] Evett I. W., 1998, INTERPRETING DNA EVI
[9] A GUIDE TO INTERPRETING SINGLE LOCUS PROFILES OF DNA MIXTURES IN FORENSIC CASES
EVETT, IW
BUFFERY, C
WILLOTT, G
STONEY, D
[J]. JOURNAL OF THE FORENSIC SCIENCE SOCIETY, 1991, 31 (01): : 41 - 47
[10] Interpreting simple STR mixtures using allele peak areas
Gill, P
Sparkes, R
Pinchin, R
Clayton, T
Whitaker, J
Buckleton, J
[J]. FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL, 1998, 91 (01) : 41 - 53

← 1 2 →