Endoscopic sinus surgery might reduce exacerbations and symptoms more than balloon sinuplasty

被引：25

作者：

Koskinen, Anni ^{[1
,2
]}

Penttila, Matti ^{[3
,4
]}

Myller, Jyri ^{[5
]}

Hammaren-Malmi, Sari ^{[6
]}

Silvola, Juha ^{[5
]}

Haahtela, Tari ^{[1
]}

Hytonen, Maija ^{[6
]}

Toppila-Salmi, Sanna ^{[1
,2
]}

机构：

[1] Univ Helsinki, Cent Hosp, Skin & Allergy Hosp, Helsinki, Finland

[2] Univ Helsinki, Transplantat Lab, Hartman Inst, Helsinki, Finland

[3] Univ Tampere, Dept Otorhinolaryngol, FIN-33101 Tampere, Finland

[4] Terveystalo Healthcare OYJ Finland, Helsinki, Finland

[5] Paijat Hame Cent Hosp, Dept Otorhinolaryngol, Lahti, Finland

[6] Univ Helsinki, Cent Hosp, Dept Otorhinolaryngol, Helsinki, Finland

来源：

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF RHINOLOGY & ALLERGY | 2012年 / 26卷 / 06期

关键词：

CHRONIC RHINOSINUSITIS; FRONTAL RECESS; ASTHMA; OUTCOMES; IMPACT; DILATATION; EXPOSURE; BIOFILMS; ADULTS;

D O I：

10.2500/ajra.2012.26.3828

中图分类号：

R76 [耳鼻咽喉科学];

学科分类号：

100213 ;

摘要：

Background: Endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS) is considered after medical therapy failure of chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS). The balloon sinuplasty dilates the natural ostium without moving mucosa or bone. It still lacks evidence from randomized controlled trials. The aim of this retrospective controlled study was to compare the symptom outcomes after maxillary sinus surgery with either the ESS or the balloon sinuplasty technique. No previous or additional sinonasal operations were accepted. Methods: Two hundred eight patients with CRS without nasal polyps underwent either balloon sinuplasty or ESS. The patients who met with the inclusion criteria (n = 45 in ESS group and n = 40 in balloon group) replied to a questionnaire of history factors, exacerbations, and a visual analog scale (VAS) scoring of the change in symptoms, on average 28 +/- 6 (mean +/- SD) months postoperatively. Results: The groups were identical in the response rate (64%), patient characteristics, and the improvement in all of the asked symptoms. Patients with CRS-related comorbidity and/or present occupational exposure had a statistically significantly better symptom reduction after ESS than after balloon sinusotomy. Moreover, the balloon sinusotomy group reported a statistically significant higher number of maxillary sinus punctures and antibiotic courses during the last 12 months. Conclusion: ESS might be superior to balloon sinuplasty, especially in patients with risk factors. There is a need to perform more controlled studies on the treatment choices of CRS.

引用

页码：E150 / E156

页数：7

共 33 条

[1] Functional endoscopic balloon dilation of sinus ostia for chronic rhinosinusitis [J].

Ahmed, Jahangir ;

Pal, Surojit ;

Hopkins, Claire ;

Jayaraj, Samuel .

COCHRANE DATABASE OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS, 2011, (07)

[2] Outcome of endoscopic sinus surgery for chronic rhinosinusitis patients: a Canadian experience [J].

Al Badaal, Y. ;

Samaha, M. .

JOURNAL OF LARYNGOLOGY AND OTOLOGY, 2010, 124 (10) :1095-1099

[3] Allergic rhinitis and its impact on asthma (ARIA) 2008 update (in collaboration with the World Health Organization, GA2LEN and AllerGen) [J].

Bousquet, J. ;

Khaltaev, N. ;

Cruz, A. A. ;

Denburg, J. ;

Fokkens, W. J. ;

Togias, A. ;

Zuberbier, T. ;

Baena-Cagnani, C. E. ;

Canonica, G. W. ;

van Weel, C. ;

Agache, I. ;

Ait-Khaled, N. ;

Bachert, C. ;

Blaiss, M. S. ;

Bonini, S. ;

Boulet, L. -P. ;

Bousquet, P. -J. ;

Camargos, P. ;

Carlsen, K. -H. ;

Chen, Y. ;

Custovic, A. ;

Dahl, R. ;

Demoly, P. ;

Douagui, H. ;

Durham, S. R. ;

van Wijk, R. Gerth ;

Kalayci, O. ;

Kaliner, M. A. ;

Kim, Y. -Y. ;

Kowalski, M. L. ;

Kuna, P. ;

Le, L. T. T. ;

Lemiere, C. ;

Li, J. ;

Lockey, R. F. ;

Mavale-Manuel, S. ;

Meltzer, E. O. ;

Mohammad, Y. ;

Mullol, J. ;

Naclerio, R. ;

Hehir, R. E. O. ;

Ohta, K. ;

Ouedraogo, S. ;

Palkonen, S. ;

Papadopoulos, N. ;

Passalacqua, G. ;

Pawankar, R. ;

Popov, T. A. ;

Rabe, K. F. ;

Rosado-Pinto, J. .

ALLERGY, 2008, 63 :8-+

[4] Unmet needs in severe chronic upper airway disease (SCUAD) [J].

Bousquet, Jean ;

Bachert, Claus ;

Canonica, Giorgio W. ;

Casale, Thomas B. ;

Cruz, Alvaro A. ;

Lockey, Richard J. ;

Zuberbier, Torsten .

JOURNAL OF ALLERGY AND CLINICAL IMMUNOLOGY, 2009, 124 (03) :428-433

[5] Comparison of outcomes of simple polypectomy plus balloon catheter dilatation versus functional endoscopic sinus surgery in nasal polyposis: A preliminary study [J].

Bozdemir, Kazim ;

Kutluhan, Ahmet ;

Cetin, Huseyin ;

Yalciner, Gokhan ;

Bilgen, Akif Sinan .

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF RHINOLOGY & ALLERGY, 2011, 25 (03) :198-200

[6] Job choice and the influence of prior asthma and hay fever [J].

Butland, Barbara K. ;

Ghosh, Rebecca ;

Strachan, David P. ;

Cullinan, Paul ;

Jarvis, Deborah .

OCCUPATIONAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL MEDICINE, 2011, 68 (07) :494-501

[7] Adverse respiratory outcomes associated with occupational exposures at a soy processing plant [J].

Cummings, K. J. ;

Gaughan, D. M. ;

Kullman, G. J. ;

Beezhold, D. H. ;

Green, B. J. ;

Blachere, F. M. ;

Bledsoe, T. ;

Kreiss, K. ;

Cox-Ganser, J. .

EUROPEAN RESPIRATORY JOURNAL, 2010, 36 (05) :1007-1015

[8] European Position Paper on Rhinosinusitis and Nasal Polyps 2020 [J].

Fokkens, Wytske J. ;

Lund, Valerie J. ;

Hopkins, Claire ;

Hellings, Peter W. ;

Kern, Robert ;

Reitsma, Sietze ;

Toppila-Salmi, Sanna ;

Bernal-Sprekelsen, Manuel ;

Mullol, Joaquim ;

Alobid, Isam ;

Anselmo-Lima, Wilma Terezinha ;

Bachert, Claus ;

Baroody, Fuad ;

von Buchwald, Christian ;

Cervin, Anders ;

Cohen, Noam ;

Constantinidis, Jannis ;

De Gabory, Ludovic ;

Desrosiers, Martin ;

Diamant, Zuzana ;

Douglas, Richard G. ;

Gevaert, Philippe H. ;

Hafner, Anita ;

Harvey, Richard J. ;

Joos, Guy F. ;

Kalogjera, Livije ;

Knill, Andrew ;

Kocks, Janwillem H. ;

Landis, Basile N. ;

Limpens, Jacqueline ;

Lebeer, Sarah ;

Lourenco, Olga ;

Matricardi, Paolo M. ;

Meco, Cem ;

O'Mahony, Liam ;

Philpott, Carl M. ;

Ryan, Dermot ;

Schlosser, Rodney ;

Senior, Brent ;

Smith, Timothy L. ;

Teeling, Thijs ;

Tomazic, Peter Valentin ;

Wang, De Yun ;

Wang, Dehui ;

Zhang, Luo ;

Agius, Adrian M. ;

Ahlstrom-Emanuelsson, Cecilia ;

Alabri, Rashid ;

Albu, Silviu ;

Alhabash, Saied .

RHINOLOGY, 2020, 58 :1-464

[9] Functional endoscopic dilatation of the sinuses: Patient satisfaction, postoperative pain, and cost [J].

Friedman, Michael ;

Schalch, Paul ;

Lin, Hsin-Ching ;

Mazloom, Narges ;

Neidich, Marci ;

Joseph, Ninos J. .

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF RHINOLOGY, 2008, 22 (02) :204-209

[10] Chronic rhinosinusitis in Europe - an underestimated disease. A GA2LEN study [J].

Hastan, D. ;

Fokkens, W. J. ;

Bachert, C. ;

Newson, R. B. ;

Bislimovska, J. ;

Bockelbrink, A. ;

Bousquet, P. J. ;

Brozek, G. ;

Bruno, A. ;

Dahlen, S. E. ;

Forsberg, B. ;

Gunnbjornsdottir, M. ;

Kasper, L. ;

Kraemer, U. ;

Kowalski, M. L. ;

Lange, B. ;

Lundback, B. ;

Salagean, E. ;

Todo-Bom, A. ;

Tomassen, P. ;

Toskala, E. ;

van Drunen, C. M. ;

Bousquet, J. ;

Zuberbier, T. ;

Jarvis, D. ;

Burney, P. .

ALLERGY, 2011, 66 (09) :1216-1223

← 1 2 3 4 →