Communication effectiveness training improves surgical resident teaching ability

Background: An important educational objective of academic surgical programs is to train surgical teachers, Whether formal instruction of surgery residents in general principles of teaching has a role in the achievement of this objective is unproven. Study Design: We tested whether the teaching ability of surgery residents could be improved by two different interventions: (A) a lecture on communication effectiveness plus home study of their own videotaped lectures and (B) a critical review of their own videotaped lectures with a teaching consultant. Each resident taught four sessions, There was no intervention between sessions 1 and 2; intervention A occurred between sessions 2 and 3; and intervention B, between sessions 3 and 4, Each of the four videotaped sessions was graded for communication effectiveness using a standardized scoring form. Results: There were no significant differences between scores from lectures 1 and 2 (no intervention) or lectures 2 and 3 (intervention A), Intervention B (individualized feedback) resulted in significant improvement in all scores from session 4 compared with sessions 1 and 2: content 3.40 versus 2.98 (p = 0.01), language 3.43 versus 3.22 (p = 0.03), delivery 3.25 versus 2.87 (p = 0.002), and overall 3.43 versus 2.88 (p = 0.002). Conclusions: Surgical resident teaching ability can be improved by communication effectiveness teaching. Individualized feedback is more effective than a lecture combined with self-study. (C) 1997 by the American College of Surgeons.