A pragmatic solution to Ostertag's puzzle

被引:2
作者
Atkins, Philip [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Calif Santa Barbara, Dept Philosophy, Santa Barbara, CA 93106 USA
关键词
Russellianism; Belief reports; Frege's puzzle; Semantics; Pragmatics; ASCRIPTION;
D O I
10.1007/s11098-011-9819-x
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
Gary Ostertag (Philos Stud 146:249-267, 2009) has presented a new puzzle for Russellianism about belief reports. He argues that Russellians do not have the resources to solve this puzzle in terms of pragmatic phenomena. I argue to the contrary that the puzzle can be solved according to Nathan Salmon's (Frege's puzzle, 1986) pragmatic account of belief reports, provided that the account is properly understood. Specifically, the puzzle can be solved so long as Salmon's guises are not identified with sentences.
引用
收藏
页码:359 / 365
页数:7
相关论文
共 46 条
  • [31] The Number of Moons Is Not a Number Towards a Comprehensive Linguistic Approach to Frege's Commitment Puzzle
    Jastrzebski, Borys
    [J]. FILOZOFIA NAUKI, 2016, 24 (02): : 31 - +
  • [32] Utilizing Pragmatic Frames as an analytical tool for children's performance during word learning
    Rohlfing, Katharina J.
    Grimminger, Angela
    [J]. 2019 JOINT IEEE 9TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON DEVELOPMENT AND LEARNING AND EPIGENETIC ROBOTICS (ICDL-EPIROB), 2019, : 81 - 86
  • [33] A Pragmatic Analysis of Shakespeare's Richard III: Language Strategies: Persuasion, Domination, and Control
    Macias-Borrego, Manuel
    [J]. HUMANITIES-BASEL, 2025, 14 (02):
  • [34] Pragmatic analysis of King Abdullah's speech: exploring speech acts and societal context
    Khater, Heba Ahmad
    Altakhaineh, Abdel Rahman Mitib
    Dahnous, Farah
    [J]. COGENT ARTS & HUMANITIES, 2024, 11 (01):
  • [35] Predicting Pragmatic Cue Integration in Adults' and Children's Inferences About Novel Word Meanings
    Bohn, Manuel
    Tessler, Michael Henry
    Merrick, Megan
    Frank, Michael C.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-GENERAL, 2022, 151 (11) : 2927 - 2942
  • [36] Pragmatic skills in the early stages of Alzheimer's disease: an analysis by means of a referential communication task
    Feyereisen, Pierre
    Berrewaerts, Joelle
    Hupet, Michel
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LANGUAGE & COMMUNICATION DISORDERS, 2007, 42 (01) : 1 - 17
  • [37] Economy and/or health: a pragmatic analysis of the Bolsonaro government's position in the digital environment during the pandemic
    Figueira, Mayra Duarte
    Neves-Hora, Lidia Gurguel
    Hora, Daniel de Souza Neves
    [J]. SOLETRAS, 2022, (43): : 134 - 156
  • [38] Tribal politics, tribal press, plural contexts? Pragmatic analysis of news discourse on Kenya's crisis
    Coesemans, Roel
    [J]. IC-REVISTA CIENTIFICA DE INFORMACION Y COMUNICACION, 2013, (10): : 179 - 200
  • [39] "Sorry, that's all I know!": A study on web-based pragmatic instruction for novice learners
    Kerber, Noelle
    Shea, Jacqueline
    Tecedor, Marta
    [J]. FOREIGN LANGUAGE ANNALS, 2023, 56 (03) : 645 - 666
  • [40] Effects of semantic and pragmatic factors on preschool children's negation-triggered inferences on possible alternatives
    Zhang, Xiaowen
    Zhou, Peng
    [J]. JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL CHILD PSYCHOLOGY, 2024, 247