Validation of the International Guide for Monitoring Child Development demonstrates good sensitivity and specificity in four diverse countries

被引:37
作者
Ertem, Ilgi Ozturk [1 ]
Krishnamurthy, Vibha [2 ]
Mulaudzi, Mphelekedzeni C. [3 ]
Sguassero, Yanina [4 ]
Bilik, Burcu [1 ]
Srinivasan, Roopa [2 ]
Balta, Hakan [1 ]
Gulumser, Ozlem [1 ]
Gan, Geliang [5 ]
Calvocoressi, Lisa [5 ]
Johnson, Benjamin [5 ]
Shabanova, Veronika [6 ]
Forsyth, Brian W. C. [6 ]
机构
[1] Ankara Univ, Dept Paediat, Dev Behav Paediat Div, Sch Med, Ankara, Turkey
[2] Ummeed Child Dev Ctr, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
[3] Univ Pretoria, Kalafong Hosp, Pretoria, South Africa
[4] Perinatal Study Ctr Rosario, Rosario, Santa Fe, Argentina
[5] Yale Univ, Sch Publ Hlth, Yale Ctr Analyt Sci, New Haven, CT USA
[6] Yale Univ, Sch Med, Dept Paediat, New Haven, CT USA
关键词
Developmental assessment; Early childhood development; Early intervention; Monitoring; Screening; Validation; SCREENING-TESTS; INCOME; SCALE; TOOLS; DELAY;
D O I
10.1111/apa.14661
中图分类号
R72 [儿科学];
学科分类号
100202 ;
摘要
Aim It is of critical importance to have internationally constructed tools to address early childhood development. The aim of this second phase of a two-phase study was to examine the sensitivity and specificity of the Guide for Monitoring Child Development (GMCD) in identifying developmental delay in four diverse countries. Methods The first phase of this 2011-2015 back-to-back study included 4949 children up to 42 months of age from primary healthcare centres in Argentina, India, South Africa and Turkey. Distribution curves were generated to show the ages when the children attained GMCD milestones and those that could be used across sexes and countries were placed in age ranges corresponding to the 85th and 97th percentile point estimates. Phase two examined a separately recruited sample of children in those countries to determine sensitivity and specificity of the GMCD. Results The validation phase of the 85 milestones in the GMCD identified delayed development in 30% of the 1731 children in the four countries. The sensitivity and specificity ranged from 0.71-0.94 and 0.69-0.82, respectively, for the total sample and the different age groups. Conclusion The GMCD standardised in four diverse countries has appropriate accuracy for identification of children with developmental delay.
引用
收藏
页码:1074 / 1086
页数:13
相关论文
共 30 条
[1]   Missed opportunities in surveillance and screening systems to detect developmental delay: A developing country perspective [J].
Aly, Zarmeneh ;
Taj, Fawad ;
Ibrahim, Shahnaz .
BRAIN & DEVELOPMENT, 2010, 32 (02) :90-97
[2]   Assessing developmental delay in early childhood concerns with the Bayley-III scales [J].
Anderson, Peter J. ;
Burnett, Alice .
CLINICAL NEUROPSYCHOLOGIST, 2017, 31 (02) :371-381
[3]  
[Anonymous], WORLD REP DIS
[4]  
[Anonymous], 2019, Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development Australian and New Zealand Standardised
[5]   Trends in the Prevalence of Developmental Disabilities in US Children, 1997-2008 [J].
Boyle, Coleen A. ;
Boulet, Sheree ;
Schieve, Laura A. ;
Cohen, Robin A. ;
Blumberg, Stephen J. ;
Yeargin-Allsopp, Marshalyn ;
Visser, Susanna ;
Kogan, Michael D. .
PEDIATRICS, 2011, 127 (06) :1034-1042
[6]   Enrolment and baseline characteristics in the WHO Multicentre Growth Reference Study [J].
de Onis, Mercedes ;
Onyango, Adelheid ;
Borghi, Elaine ;
Siyam, Amani ;
Pinol, Alain ;
Garza, Cutberto ;
De Onis, Mercedes ;
Martines, Jose ;
Martorell, Reynaldo ;
Victora, Cesar G. ;
Bhan, Maharaj K. ;
de Onis, Mercedes ;
Martines, Jose ;
Onyango, Adelheid ;
Pinol, Alain ;
Victora, Cesar G. ;
Araujo, Cora Luiza ;
Lartey, Anna ;
Owusu, William B. ;
Bhan, Maharaj K. ;
Bhandari, Nita ;
Norum, Kaare R. ;
Aa, Gunn-Elin ;
Mohamed, Ali Jaffer ;
Dewey, Kathryn G. ;
Garza, Cutberto ;
Belbase, Krishna ;
Black, Maureen ;
Chumles, Wm. Cameron ;
Cole, Tim ;
Frongillo, Edward ;
Grummer-Strawn, Laurence ;
Martorell, Reynaldo ;
Shrimpton, Roger ;
Van den Broeck, Jan ;
Araujo, Cora Luiza ;
Victora, Cesar G. ;
Albernaz, Elaine ;
Tomasi, Elaine ;
de Cassia Fossati da Silveira, Rita ;
Nader, Gisele ;
Lartey, Anna ;
Owusu, William B. ;
Sagoe-Moses, Isabella ;
Gomez, Veronica ;
Sagoe-Moses, Charles ;
Bhandari, Nita ;
Bhan, Maharaj K. ;
Taneja, Sunita ;
Rongsen, Temsunaro .
ACTA PAEDIATRICA, 2006, 95 :7-15
[7]   Poverty and Child Health in the United States [J].
Duffee, James H. ;
Kuo, Alice A. ;
Gitterman, Benjamin A. ;
Gitterman, Benjamin A. ;
Flanagan, Patricia J. ;
Cotton, William H. ;
Dilley, Kimberley J. ;
Duffee, James H. ;
Green, Andrea E. ;
Keane, Virginia A. ;
Krugman, Scott D. ;
Linton, Julie M. ;
McKelvey, Carla D. ;
Nelson, Jacqueline L. ;
Douge, Jacqueline R. ;
Chilton, Lance A. ;
Gambon, Thresia B. ;
Kuo, Alice A. ;
Paz-Soldan, Gonzalo J. ;
Zind, Barbara ;
Ajayi, Toluwalase ;
Choi, Ricky Y. ;
Dunston, Frances J. ;
Ivancic, M. Edward ;
Pascoe, John M. ;
Wood, David ;
Rodgers, Anne Brown ;
Watson, Camille ;
Yogman, Michael ;
Bauer, Nerissa ;
Gambon, Thresia B. ;
Lavin, Arthur ;
Lemmon, Keith M. ;
Mattson, Gerri ;
Rafferty, Jason Richard ;
Wissow, Lawrence Sagin ;
Berry, Sharon ;
Carmichael, Terry ;
Christophersen, Edward ;
Johnson, Norah ;
Sulik, Leonard Read ;
Cohen, George J. ;
Domain, Stephanie .
PEDIATRICS, 2016, 137 (04)
[8]  
Ertem I.O., 2017, EARLY CHILDHOOD MATT, P83
[9]   A guide for monitoring child development in low- and middle-income countries [J].
Ertem, Ilgi O. ;
Dogan, Derya G. ;
Gok, Canan G. ;
Kizilates, Sevim U. ;
Caliskan, Ayliz ;
Atay, Gulsum ;
Vatandas, Nilgun ;
Karaaslan, Tugba ;
Baskan, Sevgi G. ;
Cicchetti, Domenic V. .
PEDIATRICS, 2008, 121 (03) :E581-E589
[10]   Similarities and differences in child development from birth to age 3 years by sex and across four countries: a cross-sectional, observational study [J].
Ertem, Ilgi Ozturk ;
Krishnamurthy, Vibha ;
Mulaudzi, Mphelekedzeni C. ;
Sguassero, Yanina ;
Balta, Hakan ;
Gulumser, Ozlem ;
Bilik, Burcu ;
Srinivasan, Roopa ;
Johnson, Benjamin ;
Gan, Geliang ;
Calvocoressi, Lisa ;
Shabanova, Veronika ;
Forsyth, Brian W. C. .
LANCET GLOBAL HEALTH, 2018, 6 (03) :E279-E291