Correlation between Performances of Hollow Fibers and Flat Membranes for Gas Separation

This work presents an attempt at correlating the available permeability/selectivity literature data for hollow fibers and flat membranes. Therefore, this paper gathers the information pertaining to membrane materials for which membrane properties of flat membranes and hollow fibers have both been reported. An overview of the relations between selectivity and permeance of hollow fiber membranes for various gas pairs (O-2/N-2, CO2/CH4, CO2/N-2, H-2/N-2, H-2/CO2, H-2/CH4 and He/N-2) is presented first. The upper bound lines are the ones proposed by Robeson, which were calculated by assuming a one-micron-thick skin layer as proposed by Robeson in 2008. From the results obtained, a relation between the selectivity ratio in both kinds of membranes (alpha(H)/alpha(f)) and skin layer thickness (l) calculated from flat membranes and hollow fibers gas permeation data for these pairs of gases is also presented. The skin layer thicknesses measured using seven different experimental techniques for six commercial membranes are compared. The influences of spinning parameters on the morphology and performance of hollow fiber membrane gas separation are discussed. Finally, an analysis is made of the reasons why the dense skin layer thicknesses of a hollow fiber calculated using permeance and permeability data vary for different gases and also differ from direct experimental measurements.